“Such was the corrupt
opinion of the Arians; but on this the bishops, having detected their
deceitfulness in this matter, collected from Scripture those passages
which say of Christ that He is the glory, the fountain, the stream, and
the express image of the person; and they quoted the following words:
‘In thy light we shall see light Ps. xxvi. 9;’ and likewise, ‘I and
the Father are one Joh. x. 30.’ They then,
with still greater clearness, briefly declared that the Son is of one
substance with the Father; for this, indeed, is the signification of
the passages which have been quoted. The complaint of the Arians, that
these precise words are not to be found in Scripture, is proved
groundless by their own practice, for their own impious assertions are
not taken from Scripture; for it is not written that the Son is of the
non-existent, and that there was a time when He was not: and yet they
complain of having been condemned by expressions which, though not
actually in Scripture, are in accordance with true religion. They
themselves, on the other hand, as though they had found their words on
a dunghill, uttered things verily of earth. The bishops, on the
contrary, did not find their expressions for themselves; but, received
their testimony from the fathers, and wrote accordingly. Indeed, there
were bishops of old time, nearly one hundred and thirty years ago, both
of the great city of Rome and of our own city Alexandria. The allusion, according to Valesius, is to Dionysius,
Bishop of Rome, 259–269, and to Dionysius, Bishop of Alexandria.
The Letter of Athanasius to the Africans was written, according to
Baronius, in 369. So τριῶν may suit
the chronology better than τριάκοντα,
who condemned those who asserted that the Son is a creature, and that
He is not of one substance with the Father. Eusebius, the bishop of
Cæsarea, was acquainted with these facts; he, at one time,
favoured the Arian heresy, but he afterwards signed the confession of
faith of the Council of Nicæa. He wrote to the people of his
diocese, maintaining that the word ‘consubstantial’ was
‘used by illustrious bishops and learned writers as a term for
expressing the divinity of the Father and of the Son Ath.
Ep. ad Afros 5 and 6..’”