and after the rudiments of this world, not according to Christ; for in Him dwelleth all the
fulness of Godhead in bodily shape.”968
42. For they store up all the strength of their poisons in dialetical disputation, which by
the judgment of philosophers is defined as having no power to establish aught, and aiming
only at destruction.969 But it was not by dialectic that it pleased God to save His people; “for
the kingdom of God consisteth in simplicity of faith, not in wordy contention.”970
968 It would, I think, be unfair to construe this passage into an absolute condemnation of all the results of
human activity, arrived at without any conscious dependence on what we mean by revelation. We must remember,
too, what “philosophy” was in the world into which St. Paul was born. It was no longer the golden age of philo-
sophic activity—with the exception of Stoicism, there was hardly a school which exerted any elevating moral
influence. Besides, the “philosophy” of which St. Paul was especially thinking when he wrote the passage cited
(Col. iii. 8, 9) was hardly worthy of the name. It was one of the earliest forms of Gnosticism, and among other
practices inculcated worship of angels, i.e. of created beings—“Thrones, Dominations, Princedoms, Virtues,
Powers.” See Col. i. 16–18; Eph. i. 20–22. Such “philosophies,” falsely so-called, would tend to bring philosophy
in general into disfavour with the teachers of the Church. Yet we find Eusebius, in the fourth century, calling
the Faith “the true philosophy” (H. E. IV. 8). The adoption of the term to denote what St. Luke called “the way”
(Acts xix. 23) appears to have been due to the action of apologists like Justin Martyr, who set themselves to meet
the wise of this world with their own weapons, on their own ground.
969 The original conception of Dialectic, as exhibited, for instance, in Plato’s Republic, hardly answers to this.
According to Plato, the aim of Dialectic, so far from being destructive, was distinctly edifying. The Dialectic
method, as its name implies, was one which took the external form of question and answer. It had a definite,
positive object, viz., the attainment by force of pure reason to the clear vision of the Absolute Good, the ultimate
cause of knowledge and existence. The sphere of Dialectic was pure reason, then, and its object the ultimate
truth of things. (Republic, VII. p. 532.) The method which St. Ambrose here calls “Dialectic” would have been
more correctly entitled “Elenchus.”
970 1 Cor. iv. 20. Cf. ii. 4, 5.
457
Chapter V. The various blasphemies uttered by the Arians against Christ…