A sketch of the life of
Theodoret might well be supposed to terminate with his death. But it
can hardly be regarded as complete without a brief supplementary notice
of the posthumous controversy which has contributed to his fame in
ecclesiastical history. The Council of Chalcedon was designed to give
rest to the Church, and to undo a great wrong, and catholic common
sense has since vindicated its decisions. But it was not to be supposed
that the opinions and passions which had achieved a combined triumph at
Ephesus in 449 would die away and disappear in consequence of the
imperial and synodical action of 451. The face of the world was
changing. The vandal Genseric captured and pillaged Rome. The Teutonic
races were pushing to a foremost place, and accepting first of all an
Arian Christianity. Clovis represented orthodoxy almost alone.
Theodoric, the Arian Ostrogoth, mastered Italy. Then the turning tide
saw Rome once again a city of sole empire, but not the chief city. The
victories of Belisarius made of Rome a suburb of Constantinople, and
empire and theology swayed and were swayed by the policy of Justinian
and the palace plots of Theodora. All through monophysitism had had its
friends and defenders. Metropolitans, monks, and mobs had anathematized
one another for nearly a century. At Alexandria Dioscorus had won
almost a local canonization, and the patriarch Timotheus, nicknamed
“the Cat,” had left a strong monophysite party,
consolidated under Peter the Stutterer as the “acephali.” ᾽Ακέφαλοι = headless, i.e., without bishop. At Antioch Peter the Fuller had
anathematized all who refused to accept the Shibboleth he appended to
the Trisagion, “who wast crucified on our account.” Leo,
Marcian’s successor on the Eastern throne, had followed
Marcian’s theology, and Zeno, Leo; but the usurper Basiliscus had
seen elements of strength in a bold bid for monophysite support. Zeno,
on the fall of Basiliscus, had attempted to atone the disunited
sections of Christendom by the henoticon, or edict of unity, but the
henoticon had been for years a watchword of division. Anastasius had
favoured the Eutychians. And in his reign Theodoret had been twice
condemned, at the synods of Constantinople and Sidon, in 499 and 512. Victor: Turon: and Mansi, viii. 371, Mansi, viii.
197–200.