It is probably due to the accidents of time that
our present copies of the Homilies are imperfect. We are, indeed,
better off than was Jerome. His manuscript contained Homilies on
Psalms 1, 2, 51–62, 118–150, according to the Latin
notation. We have, in addition to these, Homilies which are
certainly genuine on Psalms 13, 14, 63–69; and others on the
titles of Psalms 9 and 91, which are probably spurious So Zingerle, Preface,
p. xiv, to whom we owe the excellent Vienna Edition of the Homilies,
the only part of Hilary’s writing which has as yet appeared in a
critical text. The writer of the former of these two Homilies, in
§ 2, says that the title of a Psalm always corresponds to the
contents. This is quite contrary to Hilary’s teaching, who
frequently points out and ingeniously explains what seem to him, to be
discrepancies.. Some more Homilies of uncertain
origin which have been fathered upon Hilary, and may be found in the
editions, may be left out of account. In the Homily on Psalm 59,
§ 2, he mentions one, unknown to Jerome as to ourselves, on Psalm
44; and this allusion, isolated though it is, suggests that the
Homilies contained, or were meant to contain, a commentary on the whole
Book of Psalms, composed in the order in which they stand. There
is, of course, nothing strange in the circulation in ancient times of
imperfect copies; a well-known instance is that of St.
Augustine’s copy of Cyprian which did not contain an epistle
which has come down to us. This series of Homilies was probably
continuous as well as complete. The incidental allusions to the
events of the times contain nothing inconsistent with the supposition
that he began at the beginning of the Psalter and went on to the
end. We might, indeed, construe the language of that on Psalm 52,
§ 13, concerning prosperous clergy, who heap up wealth for
themselves and live in luxury, as an allusion to men like Saturninus,
but the passage is vague, and a vivid recollection, not a present evil, may have suggested
it. More definite, and indeed a clear note of time, is the Homily
on Psalm 63, where heathenism is aggressive and is become a real
danger, of which Hilary speaks in the same terms as he does of
heresy. This contrasts strongly with such language as that of the
Homily on Psalm 67, § 20, where the heathen are daily flocking
into the Church, or of that on Psalm 137, § 10, where paganism has
collapsed, its temples are ruined and its oracles silent; such words as
the former could only have been written in the short reign of
Julian. Other indications, such as the frequent warnings against
heresy and denunciations of heretics, are too general to help in fixing
the date. On the whole, it would seem a reasonable hypothesis
that Hilary began his connected series of Homilies on the Psalms
soon after his return to Gaul, that he had made good progress with them
when Julian publicly apostatised, and that they were not completed till
the better times of Valentinian.