The first extant notice of Melito, bishop of Sardis, is found in
the letter addressed by Polycrates to Bishop Victor of Rome (c.
190–202 a.d.) in support of the
Quartodeciman practice of the Asia Minor churches. A fragment of this
letter is given by Eusebius in Bk. V. chap. 24, and from it we learn
that Melito also favored the Quartodeciman practice, that he was a man
whose walk and conversation were altogether under the influence of the
Holy Spirit, and that he was buried at Sardis. Polycrates in this
fragment calls Melito a eunuch. Whether the word is to be understood in
its literal sense or is to be taken as meaning simply that Melito lived
in “virgin continence” is disputed. In favor of the latter
interpretation may be urged the fact that the Greek word and its Latin
equivalent were very commonly used by the Fathers in this figurative
sense, e.g. by Athenagoras, by Tertullian, by Clement of Alexandria, by
Cassianus (whose work on continence bore the title περὶ
ἐγκρατείας, ἢ
περὶ
εὐνουχίας), by Jerome, Epiphanius, Chrysostom, Theodoret, Gregory
Nazianzen, &c. (see Smith and Wace’s Dict. of Christ.
Biog., article Melito, and Suicer’s Thesaurus).
On the other hand, such continence cannot have been a rare thing in
Asia Minor in the time of Polycrates, and the fact that Melito is
called specifically “the eunuch” looks peculiar if nothing
more than that is meant by it. The case of Origen, who made himself a
eunuch for the sake of preserving his chastity, at once occurs to us in
this connection (see Renan, L’eglise chret. p. 436, and
compare Justin Martyr’s Apol. I. 29). The canonical rule
that no such eunuch could hold clerical office came later, and hence
the fact that Melito was a bishop cannot be urged against the literal
interpretation of the word here. Polycrates’ meaning hardly
admits of an absolute decision, but at least it cannot be looked upon
as it is by most historians as certain that he uses the word here in
its figurative sense.
Polycrates says nothing of the
fact that Melito was a writer, but we learn from this chapter
(§4), and from Bk. VI. chap. 13, that Clement of Alexandria, in a
lost work, mentioned his writings and even wrote a work in reply to one
of his (see below, note 23). According to the present chapter he was a
very prolific writer, and that he was a man of marked talent is clear
from Jerome’s words in his de vir. ill. chap. 24 (where he
refers to Tertullian’s lost work, de Ecstasi):
Hujus [i.e. Melitonis] elegans et declamatorium
ingenium Tertullianus in septem libris, quos scripsit adversus
ecclesiam pro Montano, cavillatur, dicens eum a plerisque nostrorum
prophetam putari. In spite of the fact that Tertullian satirized
Melito’s talent, he nevertheless was greatly influenced by his
writings and owed much to them (see the points of contact between the
two men given by Harnack, p. 250 sqq.). The statement that he was
regarded by many as a prophet accords well with Polycrates’
description of him referred to above. The indications all point to the
fact that Melito was decidedly ascetic in his tendencies, and that he
had a great deal in common with the spirit which gave rise to Montanism
and even made Tertullian a Montanist, and yet at the same time he
opposed Montanism, and is therefore spoken of slightingly by
Tertullian. His position, so similar to that of the Montanists, was not
in favor with the orthodox theologians of the third century, and this
helps to explain why, although he was such a prolific and talented
writer, and although he remained orthodox, he nevertheless passed
almost entirely out of the memory of the Church of the third and
following centuries. To this is to be added the fact that Melito was a
chiliast; and the teachings of the Montanists brought such disrepute
upon chiliasm that the Fathers of the third and following centuries did
not show much fondness for those who held or had held these views. Very
few notices of Melito’s works are found among the Fathers, and
none of those works is to-day extant. Eusebius is the first to give us
an idea of the number and variety of his writings, and he does little
more than mention the titles, a fact to be explained only by his lack
of sympathy with Melito’s views.
The time at which Melito lived
is indicated with sufficient exactness by the fact that he wrote his
Apology during the reign of Marcus Aurelius, but after the death
of his brother Lucius, i.e. after 169 (see below, note 21); and that
when Polycrates wrote his epistle to Victor of Rome, he had been dead
already some years. It is possible (as held by Piper, Otto, and others)
that his Apology was his last work, for Eusebius mentions it
last in his list. At the same time, it is quite as possible that
Eusebius enumerates Melito’s works simply in the order in which
he found them arranged in the library of Cæsarea, where he had
perhaps seen them. Of the dates of his episcopacy, and of his
predecessors and successors in the see of Sardis, we know
nothing.
In addition to the works
mentioned in this chapter by Eusebius, who does not pretend to give a
full list, we find in Anastasius Sinaita’s Hodegos seu dux
viæ c. aceph. fragments from two other works entitled
εἰς τὸ
π€θος and
περὶ
σαρκώσεως
χριστοῦ (the latter directed against Marcion), which cannot be identified
with any mentioned by Eusebius (see Harnack, I. 1, p. 254). The
Codex Nitriacus Musei Britannici 12,156 contains four fragments
ascribed to Melito, of which the first belongs undoubtedly to his
genuine work περὶ ψυχῆς
καὶ
σώματος,
which is mentioned in this chapter by Eusebius. The second purports to
be taken from a work, περὶ
σταυροῦ, of
which we hear nowhere else, and which may or may not have been by
Melito. The third fragment bears the title Melitonis episcopi de
fide, and might be looked upon as an extract from the work
περὶ
πίστεως,
mentioned by Eusebius (as Otto regards it); but the same fragment is
four times ascribed to Irenæus by other early authorities, and an
analysis of these authorities shows that the tradition in favor of
Irenæus is stronger than that in favor of Melito, and so Harnack
mentions a work, περὶ
πίστεως,
which is ascribed by Maximus Confessor to Irenæus, and from which
the quotation may have been taken (see Harnack, ibid. p. 266
ff.). The fourth fragment was taken in all probability from
Melito’s work, περὶ
π€θους,
mentioned by Anastasius. An Apology in Syriac, bearing the name of
Melito, is extant in another of the Nitrian mss. in the British Museum (No. 14,658), and has been
published with an English translation by Cureton, in his Spic.
Syr. (p. 41–51). It has been proved, however, that this
Apology (which we have entire) was not written by Melito, but probably
by an inhabitant of Syria, in the latter part of the second, or early
part of the third century,—whether originally in the Greek or
Syriac language is uncertain (see Harnack, p. 261 ff., and Smith and
Wace, Vol. III. p. 895). In addition to the genuine writings, there
must be mentioned also some spurious works which are still extant. Two
Latin works of the early Middle Ages, entitled de transitu
Mariæ and de passione S. Joannis Evangelistæ, and
also a Catena of the latter Middle Ages on the Apocalypse, and a
Clavis Scripturæ of the Carlovingian period (see below,
note 18), bear in some mss. the name of
Melito. This fact shows that Melito’s name was not entirely
forgotten in the Occidental Church of the Middle Ages, though little
exact knowledge of him seems to have existed.
On Melito and his
writings, see Piper’s article in the Theol. Studien und
Kritiken, 1838, p. 54–154; Salmon’s article in Smith
and Wace, and especially Harnack’s Texte und Unters. I. 1,
p. 240–278. The extant fragments of Melito’s writings are
given in Routh’s Rel. Sac. I. 111–153, and in
Otto’s Corp. Apol. IX. 374–478, and an English
translation in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. VIII. p.
750–762.