The test formula of Nicæa was the work of
two concurrent influences, that of the anti-Origenists of the East,
especially Marcellus of Ancyra, Eustathius of Antioch, supported by
Macarius of ‘Ælia,’ Hellanicus of Tripolis, and
Asclepas of Gaza, and that of the Western bishops, especially Hosius of
Cordova. The latter fact explains the energetic intervention of Constantine at the critical moment on
behalf of the test (see below, and Ep. Eus. p. 75); the word was
commended to the Fathers by Constantine, but Constantine was
‘prompted’ by Hosius (Harnack, Dogmg. ii. 226);
οὗτος τὴν
ἐν Νικαί& 139·
πίοτιν
ἐξέθετο (infr. p.
285, §42). Alexander (the Origenist) had been prepared for this by
Hosius beforehand (Soc. iii. 7; Philost. i. 7; cf. Zahn Marcell.
p. 23, and Harnack’s important note, p. 229). Least of all was
Athanasius the author of the ὁμοούσιον; his
whole attitude toward the famous test (infr. p. 303) is that of
loyal acceptance and assimilation rather than of native inward
affinity. ‘He was moulded by the Nicene Creed, did not mould it
himself’ (Loofs, p. 134). The theological keynote of the council
was struck by a small minority; Eustathius, Marcellus, perhaps
Macarius, and the Westerns, above all Hosius; the numbers were
doubtless contributed by the Egyptian bishops who had condemned Arius
in 321. The signatures, which seem partly incorrect, preserve a list of
about 20. The party then which rallied round Alexander in formal
opposition to the Arians may be put down at over thirty. ‘The men
who best understood Arianism were most decided on the necessity of its
formal condemnation.’ (Gwatkin.) To this compact and determined
group the result of the council was due, and in their struggle they
owed much—how much it is hard to determine—to the energy
and eloquence of the deacon Athanasius, who had accompanied his bishop
to the council as an indispensable companion (infr. p. 103; Soz.
i. 17 fin.). (3) Between the convinced Arians and their reasoned
opponents lay the great mass of the bishops, 200 and more, nearly all
from Syria and Asia Minor, who wished for nothing more than that they
might hand on to those who came after them the faith they had received
at baptism, and had learned from their predecessors. These were the
‘conservatives A term
first brought into currency in this connection by Mr. Gwatkin (p. 38,
note), and since adopted by many writers including Harnack; in spite of
the obvious objection to the importations of political terms into the
grave questions of this period, the term is too useful to be
surrendered, and the ‘conservatives’ of the Post-Nicene
reaction were in fact too often political in their methods and spirit.
The truly conservative men, here as in other instances, failed
to enlist the sympathy of the conservative rank and file.,’ or middle party,
composed of all those who, for whatever reason, while untainted with
Arianism, yet either failed to feel its urgent danger to the Church, or
else to hold steadily in view the necessity of an adequate test if it
was to be banished. Simple shepherds like Spyridion of Cyprus; men of
the world who were more interested in their libelli than in the
magnitude of the doctrinal issue; theologians, a numerous class,
‘who on the basis of half-understood Origenist ideas were
prepared to recognise in Christ only the Mediator appointed (no doubt
before all ages) between God and the World’ (Zahn Marc. p.
30); men who in the best of faith yet failed from lack of intellectual
clearsightedness to grasp the question for themselves; a few, possibly,
who were inclined to think that Arius was hardly used and might be
right after all; such were the main elements which made up the mass of
the council, and upon whose indefiniteness, sympathy, or unwillingness
to impose any effective test, the Arian party based their hopes at any
rate of toleration. Spokesman and leader of the middle party was the
most learned Churchman of the age, Eusebius of Cæsarea. A devoted
admirer of Origen, but independent of the school of Lucian, he had,
during the early stages of the controversy, thrown his weight on the
side of toleration for Arius. He had himself used compromising
language, and in his letter to the Cæsarean Church (infra,
p. 76 sq.) does so again. But equally strong language can be
cited from him on the other side, and belonging as he does properly to
the pre-Nicene age, it is highly invidious to make the most of his
Arianising passages, and, ignoring or explaining away those on the
other side, and depreciating his splendid and lasting services to
Christian learning, to class him summarily with his namesake of
Nicomedia The
identity of name has certainly done Eusebius no good with posterity.
But no one with a spark of generosity can fail to be moved by the
appeal of Socrates (ii. 21) for common fairness toward the
dead.. (See Prolegg. to vol. 1 of this series, and
above all the article in D.C.B.) The fact however remains, that
Eusebius gave something more than moral support to the Arians. He was
‘neither a great man nor a clear thinker’ (Gwatkin); his
own theology was hazy and involved; as an Origenist, his main dread was
of Monarchianism, and his policy in the council was to stave off at
least such a condemnation of Arianism as should open the door to
‘confounding the Persons.’ Eusebius apparently represents,
therefore, the ‘left wing,’ or the last mentioned, of the
‘conservative’ elements in the council (supra, and
Gwatkin, p. 38); but his learning, age, position, and the ascendency of
Origenist Theology in the East, marked him out as the leader of the
whole.