With regard to Gregory’s own view of the
prerogatives of the Roman See beyond the limits of its proper
metropolitan or patriarchal jurisdiction, he undoubtedly claimed for it
a primacy not of rank only, but also of authority in the Church
Universal; and this of divine right, as representing the See of the
Prince of the apostles. Such claim had come, in his day, to be
the tradition of the Roman Church, which he accepted as a matter of
course, and handed on. In assertion of this claim he says in more
than one place, “Petro totius ecclesiæ cura et principatus
commissa est;” and again, “quis nesciat sanctam Ecclesiam
in apostolorum principis soliditate firmatam.…Itaque, cum multi
sint apostoli, pro ipso tamen principatu sola apostolorum principis
sedes in auctoritate convaluit” (Lib. VII., Ep.
40); and he certainly regarded the like authority as residing still in
what was called St. Peter’s See.
But we nowhere find him asserting it in
such a way as to merge the general episcopal commission in the
Papacy, or to interfere with the canonical exercise of their
independent jurisdiction by other patriarchs of ancient Apostolic
Sees. He sent according to custom, after his accession, his
confession of faith to the four Eastern patriarchs of Alexandria,
Antioch, Jerusalem, and Constantinople, as to brethren: he never,
even where his jurisdiction was acknowledged, interfered with the free
election of bishops by their several Churches, except where he saw some
canonical impediment, reserving only to himself the right of confirming
the election (see e.g. Lib. II., Ep. 6; Lib. V.,
Ep. 17, &c.): and, lastly, his memorable emphatic
protest against the assumption of the title of Universal Bishop by the
patriarchs of Constantinople, with his total renunciation of any right
of his own to assume such a title, has often been quoted as a standing
protest against such papal supremacy as has subsequently been claimed
and exercised. He seems to have regarded the See of St. Peter as
everywhere supreme only in the sense of its being its prerogative to
conserve inviolate the catholic faith and observance of the canons,
wherever heresy or uncanonical proceedings called for protest and
correction. He writes thus to John, bishop of Syracuse, “Si
qua culpa in episcopis invenitur, nescio quis ei [Sedi
apostolicæ] subjectus non sit: cum vero culpa non
exigit, omnes secundum rationem humilitatis æquales sunt”
(Lib. IX., Ep. 59). Again, to the defensor
Romanus, “Si qua unicuique episcopo jurisdictio non servatur,
quid aliud agitur, nisi ut per nos, per quos ecclesiasticus custodiri
debuit ordo, confundatur?” (Lib. XI., Ep.
37). Again to Eulogius of Alexandria, protesting against being
addressed as Universal Pope, and against the expression, sicut
jussistis, “Quod verbum jussionis peto a meo auditu removere,
quia scio qui sum, qui estis. Loco quim mihi fratres estis,
moribus patres. Non ergo jussi, sed quæ utilia visa sunt
indicare curavi.…Nec honorem esse deputo in quo fratres meos
honorem suum perdere cognosco. Si enim universalem me Papam
vestra sanctitas dicit, negat se hoc esse, quod me fatetur
universum. Sed absit hoc.” (Lib. VIII.,
Ep. 30). Further, there is the notable fact, that he
distinctly accords to the patriarchs of Alexandria and Antioch equal
shares with himself in the primacy of St. Peter’s See;—to
the former on the ground of his See having been founded by St. Mark,
who had been sent by St. Peter; to the latter because (according to the
Clementine tradition, which he takes for granted) St. Peter had been
for seven years bishop of Antioch before he went to Rome. To
Eulogius of Alexandria he writes, “Cum ergo unius atque una sit
sedes, cui ex auctoritate divina tres nunc episcopi præsident,
quicquid ergo de vobis boni audio, hoc mihi imputo. Si quid de me
boni creditis, hoc vestris meritis imputate, quia in illo unum sumus
qui ait, Ut omnes unum sint, sicut et tu Pater in me, et ego in te,
et ipsi in nobis unum sint” (Lib. VII., Ep.
40. Cf. V. 39; X. 35; XIII. 41). He wrote thus in his
anxiety to induce those two patriarchs to support him in his resistance
to the assumptions of Constantinople; but his view of the principality
of St. Peter’s See not being vested exclusively in the See of
Rome remains no less distinctly on record. The view to which he
gives expression of the unity of the three Sees may perhaps have arisen
thus. The tradition of the peculiarly Petrine origin of the Roman
See, and hence its claim as of divine right to supremacy, having come
by this time to be accepted in the West, the undoubted ancient
jurisdiction, independently of Rome, of the great patriarchal sees of
the East in their own regions, had to be accounted for in accordance
with this theory: and hence they too were regarded as deriving
their authority from St. Peter. Accordingly we do not find
Gregory in any of his letters to the patriarchs of Alexandria and
Antioch addressing them in a tone of command. It is true that in
one letter to Eulogius of Alexandria he remonstrates with him urgently
for allowing (as was alleged) simony in his diocese; but it is
brotherly remonstrance only (Lib. XIII., Ep.
41).