In the sentence immediately preceding the above Dr.
Scruff remarks “but the peculiar Christology of Apollinaris has
reappeared from time to time in a modified shape, as isolated
theological opinion.” No doubt Dr. Schaff had in mind the
fathers of the so-called “Kenoticism” of to-day, Gess and
Ebrard, who teach, unless they have been misunderstood, that the
incarnate Son had no human intellect or rational soul (νοῦς) but that the divine
personality took its place, by being changed into it. By this
last modification, they claim to escape from the taint of the
Apollinarian heresy. The theological views
of Gess and Ebrard I know only from the statements of them in writers
on the subject of the Incarnation, especially from those made by the
Rev. A. B. Bruce, D D., Professor at Free Church College, Glasgow, in
his work “The Humiliation of Christ.” (Lecture
IV.) The following passage (cited by Dr. Bruce) seems to prove
his contention so far as Gess is concerned. “Dass eine wahrhaft menschliche Seele in Jesu war, versteht sich
für und von selbt: er war ja sonst kein wirklicher
Mensch. Aber die Frage ist, ob der in’s Werden eingegangene
Logos selbst diese menschliche Seele, oder ob neben dem in’s
Werden eingegangenen Logos noch eine becondere menschliche Seele in
Jesu war?” (Gess. Die Lehre v. d. Person
Christi, ii. p. 321.) Bruce understands Gess to teach that
“The only difference between the Logos and a human soul was, that
he became human by voluntary kenosis, while an ordinary human soul
derives its existence from a creative act.” (And refers to
Gess, ut supra, p. 325 et seqq.) For Ebrard’s
view, see his Christliche Dogmatik, ii., p. 40. Ritschl
dubbed the whole kenotic theory as “Verschämter
Socinianismus.”