CHAP. V.
Of natural conscience, and the moral sense.
There is yet another disposition or principle, of great importance, natural to mankind;
which, if we consider the consistence and harmony of nature’s laws, may also be looked
upon as, in some sort, arising from self-love, or self-union; and that is, a disposition in man
to be uneasy in a consciousness of being inconsistent with himself, and as it were against
himself in his own actions. This appears particularly in the inclination of the mind to be
uneasy in the consciousness of doing that to others, which he should be angry with them
for doing to him, if they were in his case, and he in theirs; or of forbearing to do that to
them, which he would be displeased with them for neglecting to do to him.
I have observed, from time to time, that in pure love to others, i.e. love not arising from
self-love, there is an union of the heart with others; a kind of enlargement of the mind,
whereby it so extends itself as to take others into a man’s self: and therefore it implies a
disposition to feel, to desire, and to act as though others were one with ourselves. So, self-
love implies an inclination to feel and act as one with ourselves; which naturally renders a
sensible inconsistence with ourselves, and self-opposition in what we ourselves choose and
do, to be uneasy to the mind: which will cause uneasiness of mind to be the consequence of
a malevolent and unjust behaviour towards others, and a kind of disapprobation of acts of
this nature, and an approbation of the contrary. To do that to another, which we should be
angry with him for doing to us, and to hate a person for doing that to us, which we should
incline to and insist on doing to him, if we were exactly in the same case, is to disagree with
ourselves, and contradict ourselves. It would be for ourselves both to choose and adhere to,
and yet to refuse and utterly reject, the very same thing. No wonder this is contrary to nature.
No wonder, that such a self-opposition, and inward war with a man’s self, naturally begets
unquietness, and raises disturbance in his mind.
Thus approving of actions, because we therein act as in agreement with ourselves; and
thus disapproving, and being uneasy in the consciousness of disagreeing with ourselves, in
what we do, is quite a different thing from approving or disapproving actions because in
them we are united with being in general: which is loving or hating actions from a sense of
the primary beauty of true virtue, and of the odiousness of sin. The former of these principles
is private; the latter is public, and truly benevolent in the highest sense. The former—an
inclination to agree with ourselves—is a natural principle: but the latter—an agreement or
union of heart to the great system, and to God the head of it, who is all and all in it—is a
divine principle.
In that uneasiness now mentioned, consists very much of that inward trouble men have
from reflections of conscience: and when they are free from this uneasiness, and are conscious
to themselves, that in what they have acted towards others, they have done the same which
they should have expected from them in the same case, then they have what is called peace
CHAPTER V. Natural conscience, and the moral sense.
896
CHAPTER V. Natural conscience, and the moral sense.