OBJECT. XVII.
IF a profession of godliness be a thing required in order to admission into the church,
there being some free saints who doubt of their state, and from a tender conscience will not
dare to make such a profession; and there being others, that have no grace, nor much ten-
derness of conscience, but great presumption and forwardness, who will boldly make the
highest profession of religion, and so will get admittance: it will hence come to pass, that
the very thing, which will in effect procure for the latter an admission, rather than the former,
will be their presumption and wickedness.
Answ. 1. It is no sufficient objection against the wholesomeness of a rule established for
regulating the civil state of mankind, that in some instances men’s wickedness may take ad-
vantage by that rule, so that even their wickedness shall be the very thing, which, by an abuse
of that rule, procures them temporal honours and privileges. For such is the present state of
man in this evil world, that good rules, in many instances, are liable to be thus abused and
perverted. As for instance, there are many human laws, accounted wholesome and necessary,
by which an accused or suspected person’s own solemn profession of innocency, upon oath,
shall be the condition of acquittance and impunity; and the want of such a protestation or
profession shall expose him to the punishment. And yet, by an abuse of these rules, in some
instances, nothing but the horrid sin of perjury, or that most presumptuous wickedness of
false swearing, shall be the very thing that acquits a man: while another of a more tender
conscience, who fears an oath, must suffer the penalty of the law.
2. Those rules, by all wise lawgivers, are accounted wholesome, which prove of general
good tendency, notwithstanding any bad consequences arising in some particular instances.
And as to the ecclesiastical rule now in question, of admission to sacraments on a profession
of godliness, when attended with requisite circumstances; although in particular instances
it may be an occasion of some tender-hearted Christians abstaining, and some presumptuous
sinners being admitted, yet that does not hinder but that a proper visibility of holiness to
the eye of reason, or a probability of it in a judgment of rational christian charity, may this
way be maintained, as the proper qualification of candidates for admission. Nor does it
hinder but that it may be reasonable and wholesome for mankind, in their outward conduct,
to regulate themselves by such probability; and that this should be a reasonable and good
rule for the church to regulate themselves by in their admissions; notwithstanding it may
happen in particular instances, that things are really diverse from, yea the very reverse of,
what they are visibly. Such a profession as has been insisted on, when attended with requisite
circumstances, carries in it a rational credibility in the judgment of christian charity: for it
ought to be attended with an honest and sober character, and with evidences of good doc-
trinal knowledge, and with all proper, careful, and diligent instructions of a prudent pastor.
And though the pastor is not to act as a searcher of the heart, or a lord of conscience in this
affair, yet that hinders not but that he may and ought to inquire particularly into the exper-
OBJ. XVII. True saints doubt of their state.
1867
OBJ. XVII. True saints doubt of their state.