The glory of inventing the new moral code on the
subject, by which that which before was looked upon as mortal sin has
been transfigured into innocence, if not virtue, belongs to John
Calvin! He made the modern distinction between
“interest” and “usury,” and was the first to
write in defence of this then new-fangled refinement of
casuistry. Funk (Zins und
Wucher, p. 104) says that Eck and Hoogsträten had already
verbally defended this distinction at Bologna. Luther
violently opposed him, and Melancthon also kept to the old doctrine,
though less violently (as was to be expected); today the whole
Christian West, Protestant and Catholic alike, stake their salvation
upon the truth of Calvin’s distinction! Among Roman
Catholics the new doctrine began to be defended about the beginning of
the eighteenth century, the work of Scipio Maffei, Dell’
impiego dell danaro, written on the laxer side, having attracted a
widespread attention. The Ballerini affirm that the learned pope
Benedict XIV. allowed books defending the new morals to be dedicated to
him, and in 1830 the Congregation of the Holy Office with the approval
of the reigning Pontiff, Pius VIII., decided that those who considered
the taking of interest allowed by the state law justifiable, were
“not to be disturbed.” It is entirely disingenuous to
attempt to reconcile the modern with the ancient doctrine; the Fathers
expressly deny that the State has any power to make the receiving of
interest just or to fix its rate, there is but one ground for those to
take who accept the new teaching, viz. that all the ancients, while
true on the moral principle that one must not defraud his neighbour nor
take unjust advantage of his necessity, were in error concerning the
facts, in that they supposed that money was barren, an opinion which
the Schoolmen also held, following Aristotle. This we have found
in modern times, and amid modern circumstances, to be an entire error,
as Gury, the famous modern casuist, well says, “fructum producit
et multiplicatur per se.” Gury, Comp. Theol.
Moral (Ed. Ballerini) vol. ii. p. 611.