apostatized from Christ, why is the Christian despised while furthering the interests of unity,
581
the apostate praised while favoring deceit? Constantine ordered that the basilicas should
be taken from you, Julian that they should be restored. Do you wish to know which of these
actions is conducive to Christian peace? The one was done by a man who had believed in
Christ, the other by one who had abandoned Christ. O how you would wish that you could
say, It was indeed ill done that supplication should so be made to Julian, but what has that
to do with us? But if you were to say this, the Catholic Church would also conquer in these
same words, whose saints dispersed throughout the world are much less concerned with
what you say of those towards whom you feel as you may be disposed to feel. But it is beyond
your power to say, It was ill done that supplication should so be made to Julian. Your throat
is closed; your tongue is checked by an authority close at home. It was Pontius that did it.
Pontius presented the petition; Pontius declared that the apostate was most righteous;
Pontius set forth that only righteousness found a place with the apostate. That Pontius
made a petition to him in these words, we have the express evidence of Julian himself,
mentioning him by name, without any disguise. Your representations still exist. It is no
uncertain rumor, but public documents that bear witness to the fact. Can it be, that because
the apostate made some concession to your prayer, to the detriment of the unity of Christ,
you therefore find truth in what was said, that only righteousness found a place with him?
but because Christian emperors decide against your wishes, since this appears to them most
likely to contribute to the unity of Christ, therefore they are called the foes of Christianity?
Such folly may all heretics display; and may they regain wisdom, so that they should be no
longer heretics.
206. And when is that fulfilled, you will say, which the Lord declares, "The time cometh,
that whosoever killeth you will think that he doeth God service"?2250 At any rate neither
can this be said of the heathen, who persecuted Christians, not for the sake of God, but for
the sake of their idols. You do not see that if this had been said of these emperors who rejoice
in the name of Christian, their chief command would certainly have been this, that you
should have been put to death; and this command they never gave at all. But the men of
your party, by opposing the laws in hostile fashion, bring deserved punishment on themselves;
and their own voluntary deaths, so long as they think that they bring odium on us, they
consider in no wise ruinous to themselves. But if they think that that saying of Christ refers
to kings who honor the name of Christ, let them ask what the Catholic Church suffered in
the East, when, Valens the Arian was emperor. There indeed I might find what I should
understand to be sufficient fulfillment of the saying of the Lord, "The time cometh, that
whosoever killeth you will think that he doeth God service," that heretics should not claim,
as conducing to their especial glory, the injunctions issued against their errors by Catholic
2250 John xvi. 2.
1147
Chapter 93