446 JEROME.
was the reply made by the whole body of the
brethren : not, as you maintain, that you were
not an heretic, because at a former time you
were not said to be one. For upon that
showing, a man must be said not to be sick,
because previous to his sickness he was in
good health.
40. To proceed with the letter. "But when the ordination of Paulinianus, and the
others associated with him, was brought for-
ward, they began to feeljhat they themselves
were in the wrong. For the sake of charity
and concord every concession was made to
them, and the only point insisted on was that,
though they had been ordained contrary to
the rules, yet they should be subject to the
authority of the Church of God, that they
should not rend it, and set up an authority of
their own. But they, not agreeing to this,
began to raise questions concerning the faith ;
and thus they made it evident to all that if
the presbyter Jerome and his friends were not
accused, they had no charge to bring against
us, but that they only betook themselves to
doctrinal questions because, when charges of
error and misgonduct were brought against
them, they were utterly unable to reply to us
on matters of that sort, or to give any satis-
factory explanation of their wrong-doing :
not that they had any hope that we could be
convicted of heresy, but they were striving to
injure our reputation." 41. No one must blame the translator for
this verbiage : the Greek is the same. Mean-
while I rejoice that whereas I thought I was
beheaded I find my presbyterial head on my
shoulders again. He says that we are utterly in-
capable of conviction, and he draws back from
the encounter. If the cause of discord is not
due to discussions about the faith, but springs
from the ordination of Paulinianus, is it not
the extreme of folly to give occasion to those
who seek occasion by refusing to answer ?
Confess the faith ; but do it so as to answer
the question put to you, that it may be clear
to all that the dispute is not one of faith,
but of order. For so long as you are silent
when questioned concerning the faith, your
adversary has a right to say to you : " The
matter is not one of order but of faith."
If it is a question of order, you act foolishly
in saying nothing when questioned concern-
ing the faith. If it is one of faith, it is fool-
ish of you to make a pretext of the question
of order. Moreover, when you say your aim
was that they might be subject to the Church,
that they might not rend it, nor set up an
authority of their own ; who they are of
whom you speak I do not well understand.
If you are speaking of me and the presbyter
Vincentius, you have been asleep long enough,
if you only wake up now, after thirteen years,1 to say these things. For the reason why I
forsook Antioch and he Constantinople,2 both famous cities, was, not that we might praise
your popular eloquence, but that, in the
country and in solitude, we might weep over
the sins of our youth, and draw down upon
us the mercy of Christ. But if Paulinianus is
the subject of your remarks, he, as you see,
is subject to his3 bishop, and lives at Cyprus : he sometimes comes to visit us, not as one of
your clergy, but as another's, his, namely, by whom he was ordained. But if he wished even
to stay here, and to live a quiet, solitary life
sharing our exile, what does he owe you except
the respect which we owe to all bishops ? Sup-
pose that he had been ordained by you ; he
would only tell you the same that I, a poor
wretch of a man, told Bishop Paulinus of
blessed memory. " Did I ask to be ordained by
you ? " I said. " If in bestowing the rank of presbyter you do not strip us of the monastic
state, you can bestow or withhold ordination
as you think best. But if your intention in
giving the name presbyter was to take from
me that for which I forsook the world, I
must still claim to be what I always was ; you
have suffered no loss by ordaining me." '
42. "That they might not rend the Church,"
he says, "and set up an authority of their own." Who rends the Church ? Do we, who as a
complete household at Bethlehem communi- cate in the Church ? Or is it you, who
either being orthodox refuse through pride
to speak concerning the faith, or else being heterodox are the real render of the Church ?
Do we rend the Church, who, a few months
ago, about the day of Pentecost, when the sun was darkened and all the world dreaded
the immediate coming of the Judge, presented
forty candidates of different ages and sexes
to your presbyter for baptism ? There were
certainly five presbyters in the monastery who
had the right to baptize ; but they were
unwilling to do anything to move you to
anger, for fear you might make this a pretext
for reticence concerning the faith. Is it not
you, on the contrary, who rend the Church,
you who commanded your presbyters at Beth-
lehem not to give baptism to our candidates
at Easter, so that we sent tlrem to B Diospolis to the Confessor and Bishop Dionysius for
baptism? Are we said to rend the Church,
who, outside our cells, hold no position in the
Church ? Or do not you rather rend the
Church, who issue an order to your clergy
1 Dating probably from Jerome's coming to Palestine. See Prefatory Note. 2 Jerome was ordained at Antioch, Vincentius at Constantinople.
3 That is, Jerome argues, Epiphanius, who ordained him.
4 This perhaps means, " No virtue has gone out of you — you
have conferred nothing upon me." B Lydda.