AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK I.
405
understands his offences? Clear thou me
from hidden faults, and keep back thy serv-
ant from presumptuous sins, O Lord." You should have known that the Church ad-
mits even failures through ignorance and sins
of mere thought to be offences ; so much so
that she bids sacrifices be offered for errors,
and the high priest who makes intercession
for the whole people previously offers victims
for himself. Now, if he were not himself
righteous, he would never be commanded to
offer for others. Nor, again, would he offer for
himself if he were free from sins of ignorance.
If I were to attempt to show that error and
ignorance is sin, I must roam at large over
the wide fields of Scripture.
33. C. Pray have you not read that ' " He who looks upon a woman to lust after her hath
committed adultery with her already in his
heart?" It seems that not only are the look and the allurements to vice reckoned as sin,
but whatever it be to which we give assent.
For either we can avoid an evil thought, and
consequently may be free from sin ; or, if we
cannot avoid it, that is not reckoned as sin
which cannot be avoided.
A. Your argument is ingenious, but you do
not see that it goes against Holy Scripture,
which declares that even ignorance is not
without sin. Hence it was that Job offered
sacrifices for his sons, lest, perchance, they
had unwittingly sinned in thought. And if,
when one is cutting wood, the axe-head flies
from the handle and kills a man, the owner
is 'commanded to go to one of the cities of refuge and stay there until the high priest
dies; that is to say, until he is redeemed by
the Saviour's blood, either in the baptistery, or in penitence which is a copy of the grace
of baptism, through the ineffable mercy of
the Saviour, who8 would not have any one per- ish, nor delights in the death of sinners, but
would rather that they should be converted and live.
C. It is surely strange justice to hold me
guilty of a sin of error of which my conscience does not accuse itself. I am not aware that
I have sinned, and am I to pay the penalty for
an offence of which I am ignorant ? What
more can I do, if I sin voluntarily ?
A. Do you expect me to explain the pur- poses and plans of God ? The Book of
Wisdom gives an answer to your foolish ques-
tion : 4 " Look not into things above thee,
and search not things too mighty for thee."
And elsewhere,5 " Make not thyself overwise,
and argue not more than is fitting." And in
the same place, " In wisdom and simplicity of
heart seek God." You will perhaps deny the authority of this book ; listen then to the
Apostle blowing the Gospel trumpet : "" O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and
knowledge of God ! how unsearchable are His
judgtwnts, and His ways past tracing out ! For who hath known the mind of the Lord ?
or who hath been His counsellor?" Your questions are such as he elsewhere describes :
7 " But foolish and ignorant questioning avoid,
knowing that they gender strifes." And in Ecclesiastes (a book concerning which there
can be no doubt) we read, 8" I said, I will be wise, but it was far from me. That which
is exceeding deep, who can find it out?" You ask me to tell you .why the potter makes
one vessel to honour, another to dishonour,
and will not be satisfied with Paul, who replies
on behalf of his Lord, 9 " O man, who art
thou that repliest against God ?" The remainder of this book is occupied by a series of quotations from the Old Testa-
ment, designed to show that it is not only the outer and conscious act which is reckoned
sinful, but the opposition to the Divine will, which is often implicit and half-conscious.
Occasionally, also, the speaker shows how the texts quoted enforce the argument which he
has before used, that men may be spoken of as righteous in a general sense, yet by no means
free from sins of thought or desire, if not of act.
The passages quoted are :
Gen. yiii. 21. I will not curse the ground .... for the mind of man is set on evil from his youth.
xvii. 17. xviii. 12. Abraham and Sarah laughing at the promise.
xxxvii. 35. Jacob's excessive grief . Exod. xxi. 12, 13. The guilt of one who slays another unawares.
Lev. iv. 2, 27. Offerings for sins of ignorance.
v. 3. Offerings for ceremonial uncleanness.
ix. I. Offerings for Aaron at his consecration.
xii. 6. Offerings for women after childbirth.
xiv. i, 6, xvi. 6, xii. 7. Offerings for the leper.
xv. 31, xvi. 2. 5. Offerings for the people on the day of atonement.
xxii. 14. Eating the hallowed thing:; ignorantly ; compared with I Cor. xi. 27, 28, of careless participation in the Sacrament.
Numbers vi. i. Offerings for the Nazarite.
xiv. 7, vii. 28, 29. Offerings for imploring God's mercy. xxviii. 15, 22, xxix. 5, v. n, 17. Offerings at the feasts.
tt. v. 33.
7 2 Tim. ii. 33.
1 Numb. xxxv. 6.
' Eccles. vii. 34, =5.
1 Ezek. xviii. 23. * Kom. ix. 30. 8 Eccles. vii. id.
* Rom. xi. 33. 34.