On Bk. III.
chap. 25, § 4 (note 18 continued).
The words
ἡ φερομένη
Βαρν€βα
ἐπιστολή
have been commonly translated “the so-called Epistle of
Barnabas,” or “the Epistle ascribed to Barnabas,”
implying a doubt in Eusebius’ mind as to the authenticity of the
work. This translation, however, is, in my opinion, quite unwarranted.
There are passages in Eusebius where the word
φέρομαι
used in connection with writings cannot by any possibility
be made to bear this meaning; cases in which it can be interpreted only
“to be extant” or “in circulation.” Compare,
for instance, Bk. II. chap. 15, § 1,
Μ€ρκον οὗ τὸ
εὐγγέλιον
φέρεται
;
II. 18. 6,
μονόβιβλα
αὐτοῦ
φέρεται
;
III. 9. 4; III. 16; III. 25. 3,
ἡ λεγο
μένη
᾽Ιακώβου
φέρεται
;
III. 37. 4; III. 39. 1; IV. 3. 1,
εἰσέτι δὲ
φέρεται παρὰ
πλείστοις
; IV. 14. 9,
ἐν τῇ
δηλωθείσῃ
πρὸς
φιλιππησίους
αὐτοῦ γραφῇ
φερομένῃ εἰς
δεῦρο
. Compare also
IV. 15. I; IV. 23. 4, 9, 12; IV. 24. 1; IV. 28; V. 5. 6; 19. 3; 23. 2;
24. 10; VI. 15. 1; VI. 20, &c. These passages, and many others
which are cited by Heinichen (Vol. III. p. 91), prove that the word is
frequently used in the sense of “extant” or “in
circulation.” But in spite of these numerous examples, Heinichen
maintains that the word is also used by Eusebius in another and quite
different sense; namely, “so-called” or “ascribed
to,” thus equivalent to
λεγομένη
. A careful examination, however, of all the passages cited
by him in illustration of this second meaning will show that in them
too the word may be interpreted in the same way as in those already
referred to; in fact, that in many of them that is in itself the more
natural interpretation. The passages to which we refer are Bk. III.
chap. 25, §§ 2, 3, and 4; III. 3. 1,
τὴν δὲ
φερομένην
αὐτοῦ
δευτέραν
; III. 39. 6 (where I ought to have translated “is extant
under the name of John”). To draw a distinction between the
meaning of the word as used in these and in the other passages is quite
arbitrary, and therefore unwarranted. The sense in which, as we have
found, Eusebius so commonly employs the word attaches also to the Latin
word
fertur
in the Muratorian Canon. I have not endeavored to
trace carefully the use of the word in other writers; but while many
instances occur in which it is certainly used in this sense, others in
which either interpretation is allowable, I have not yet found one in
which this meaning is ruled out by the nature of the case or by the
context. In view of these facts I believe we should be careful to draw
a sharp distinction between
λεγομένη
or
καλουμένη
and
φερομένη
when used in connection with written works.
A considerable portion of my
translation was in type before I had observed this distinction between
the two words, which is commonly quite overlooked, and as a consequence
in a few cases my rendering of the word
φερομένη
is inaccurate. All such cases I have endeavored to call
attention to in these supplementary notes.