29. Now, to prevent any one from thinking that we have devised what is so impious, we
do not call upon him to believe Heraclitus as a witness, nor to receive from his account what
he felt about such mysteries. Let him4469 ask the whole of Greece what is the meaning of
these phalli which ancient custom erects and worships throughout the country, throughout
the towns: he will find that the causes are those which we say; or if they are ashamed to declare
the truth honestly, of what avail will it be to obscure, to conceal the cause and origin of the
rite, while4470 the accusation holds good against the very act of worship? What say you, O
peoples? what, ye nations busied with the services of the temples, and given up to them? Is
it to these rites you drive us by flames, banishment, slaughter, and any other kind of punish-
ments, and by fear of cruel torture? Are these the gods whom you bring to us, whom you
thrust and impose upon us, like whom you would neither wish yourselves to be, nor any
one related to you by blood and friendship?4471 Can you declare to your beardless sons, still
wearing the dress of boys, the agreements which Liber formed with his lovers? Can you urge
your daughters-in-law, nay, even your own wives, to show the modesty of Baubo, and enjoy
the chaste pleasures of Ceres? Do you wish your young men to know, hear, and learn what
even Jupiter showed himself to more matrons than one? Would you wish your grown-up
maidens and still lusty fathers to learn how the same deity sported with his daughter? Do
you wish full brothers, already hot with passion, and sisters sprung from the same parents,
to hear that he again did not spurn the embraces, the couch of his sister? Should we not
then flee far from such gods; and should not our ears be stopped altogether, that the filthiness
of so impure a religion may not creep into the mind? For what man is there who has been
reared with morals so pure, that the example of the gods does not excite him to similar
madness? or who can keep back his desires from his kinsfolk, and those of whom he should
stand in awe, when he sees that among the gods above nothing is held sacred in the confusion
caused by4472 their lusts? For when it is certain that the first and perfect nature has not been
able to restrain its passion within right limits, why should not man give himself up to his
desires without distinction, being both borne on headlong by his innate frailty, and aided
by the teaching of the holy deities?4473
4469 i.e., the sceptic.
4470 Cumwanting in the ms..
4471 Lit. “by right of friendship.”
4472 Lit., “of.”
4473 Lit., “of holy divinity.” Orelli thinks, and with reason, that Arnobius refers to the words which Terence
puts into the mouth of Chærea (Eun., iii. 5, vv. 36–43), who encourages himself to give way to lust by asking,
“Shall I, a man, not do this?” when Jove had done as much. [Elucidation III.]
Chapter XXIX.
1207
Chapter XXIX.