But if Athanasius wrote the Vita, it does
not follow that all its less edifying details are true, nor that its
portraiture is free from subjectivity The
life of Senuti (or ‘Schnoudi’), by his disciple Visa, may
be consulted in illustration of this point. See edition by
Amélineau in vol. 4 of the Memoires de la Mission
archéologique Française au Caire, 1888.. At the same
time, to the present writer at least, the lineaments of a genuine man,
ὁμοιοπαθοῦς
ἡμῖν, stand out from the story. Doubtless
there is idealisation, panegyric, an absence of sinfulness (Gwatkin,
Studies, p. 100). But the moderate value set on miracles (38,
56), the absence of the element of fear from his religion (42,
&c.), his serene courtesy (73) and uniform cheerfulness (67, 70),
the caution against being tempted to excess in ascetic exercises (25),
the ready half-humorous good sense (73, 85) of the man, are human
touches which belong to flesh and blood, not to hagiographic
imagination. But here the question is one of individual taste. At any
rate the Vita embodies the best spirit of early monasticism. It
was the pure desire to serve God and fulfil the spirit of the Gospel
that led Antony to part with all that might make the world precious to
him, and to betake himself to his long voluntary martyrdom of solitude,
privation, and prayer. We see nothing but tenderness and love of men in
his character, nothing of the fierce bloodthirsty fanaticism which in
persons like Senuti made fifth-century monasticism a reproach to the
Christian name. Had Antony lived in our time, he might have felt that
the solitary life was a renunciation of the highest vocation of which
man is capable, the ministry to the material and spiritual needs of
others. But it is not given to man to see all aspects of truth at once
and to our bustling, comfort-loving age, even the life of Antony has
its lesson.