But his cogent proof of this
absurdity he brings forward in the words, “as the essence which
controls even Him attracts to itself the conception of the
Existent.” Let us say nothing about the awkwardness of the
combination here: let us examine his serious meaning. What argument
ever demonstrated this? He superfluously reiterates to us his statement
of the Essence of the Father having sovereignty over the Son. What
evangelist is the patron of this doctrine? What process of dialectic
conducts us to it. What premises support it? What line of argument ever
demonstrated by any logical consequence that the Only-begotten God is
under dominion? “But,” says he, “the essence that is
dominant over the Son attracts to itself the conception of the
Existent.” What is the meaning of the attraction of the existent?
and how comes the phrase of “attracting” to be flung on the
top of what he has said before? Assuredly he who considers the force of
words will judge for himself. About this, however, we will say nothing:
but we will take up again that argument that he does not grant
essential being to Him to Whom he does not leave the title of the
Existent. And why does he idly fight with shadows, contending about the
non-existent being this or that? For that which does not exist is of
course neither like anything else, nor unlike. But while granting that
He is existent he forbids Him to be so called. Alas for the vain
precision of haggling about the sound of a word while making
concessions on the more important matter! But in what sense does He,
Who, as he says, has dominion over the Son, “attract to Himself
the conception of the Existent”? For if he says that the Father
attracts His own essence, this process of attraction is superfluous:
for existence is His already, without being attracted. If, on the other
hand, his meaning is that the existence of the Son is attracted by the
Father, I cannot make out how existence is to be wrenched from the Existent,
and to pass over to Him Who “attracts” it. Can he be
dreaming of the error of Sabellius, as though the Son did not exist in
Himself, but was painted on to the personal existence of the Father? is
this his meaning in the expression that the conception of the Existent
is attracted by the essence which exercises domination over the Son? or
does he, while not denying the personal existence of the Son,
nevertheless say that He is separated from the meaning conveyed by the
term “the Existent”? And yet, how can “the
Existent” be separated from the conception of existence? For as
long as anything is what it is, nature does not admit that it should
not be what it is.