45. For in this passage, not as signifying the
Essence of His Godhead, nor His own everlasting and genuine generation
from the Father, has the Word spoken by Solomon, but on the other hand
His manhood and Economy towards us. And, as I said before, He has not
said ‘I am a creature,’ or ‘I became a
creature,’ but only ‘He created He
seems here to say that it is both true that ‘The Lord
created,’ and yet that the Son was not created. Creatures alone
are created, and He was not a creature. Rather something belonging or
relating to Him, something short of His substance or nature, was
created. However, it is a question in controversy whether even His
Manhood can be called a creature, though many of the Fathers (including
Athan. in several places) seem so to call it. On the whole it would
appear, (1.) that if ‘creature,’ like ‘Son,’ be
a personal term, He is not a creature; but if it be a word of
nature, He is a creature; (2.) that our Lord is a creature in
respect to the flesh (vid. infr. 47); (3.) that since the flesh
is infinitely beneath His divinity, it is neither natural nor safe to
call Him a creature (cf. Thom. Aq. Sum. Th. iii. xvi. 8,
‘non dicimus, quod Æthiops est albus, sed quod est albus
secundum dentes’) and (4.) that, if the flesh is worshipped,
still it is worshipped as in the Person of the Son, not by a separate
act of worship. Cf. infr. Letter 60. ad Adelph. 3. Epiph.
has imitated this passage, Ancor. 51. introducing the
illustration of a king and his robe, &c..’ For the creatures, having a created
essence, are originate, and are
said to be created, and of course the creature is created: but this
mere term ‘He created’ does not necessarily signify the
essence or the generation, but indicates something else as coming to
pass in Him of whom it speaks, and not simply that He who is said to be
created, is at once in His Nature and Essence a creature τὸ
λεγόμενον
κτίζεσθαι τῇ
φύσει καὶ τῇ
οὐσί& 139·
κτίσμα. also
infr. 60. Without meaning that the respective terms are
synonymous, is it not plain that in a later phraseology this would have
been, ‘not simply that He is in His Person a creature,’ or
‘that His Person is created?’ Athan.’s use of the
phrase οὐσία τοῦ
λόγου has already
been noticed, supr. i. 45, and passages from this Oration are
given in another connexion, supr. p. 70, note 15. The term is
synonymous with the Divine Nature as existing in the Person of the
Word. [Cf. Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2) b.] In the passage in the text
the οὐσία of the
Word is contrasted to the οὐσία of
creatures; and it is observable that it is implied that our Lord has
not taken on Him a created οὐσία.
‘He said not, Athan. remarks, ‘I became a creature, for the
creatures have a created essence;’ he adds that ‘He
created’ signifies, not essence, but something taking
place in Him περὶ
ἔκεινον,
i.e. some adjunct or accident (e.g. notes on de Decr. 22), or as
he says supr. §8, envelopment or dress. And infr.
§51, he contrasts the οὐσία and
the ἀνθρώπινον
of the Word; as in Orat. i. 41. οὐσία and ἡ ἀνθρωπότης; and φύσις and
σάρξ, iii. 34. init. and λόγος and
σάρξ, 38. init. And He speaks of the Son ‘taking on Him the
economy,’ infr. 76, and of the ὑπόστασις
τοῦ λόγου being one with ὁ
ἄνθρωπος, iv. 25, c. It is observed, §8, note, how this line of
teaching might be wrested to the purposes of the Apollinarian and
Eutychian heresies; and, considering Athan.’s most emphatic
protests against their errors in his later works, as well as his strong
statements in Orat. iii. there is no hazard in this admission.
His ordinary use of ἄνθρωπος for the manhood might quite as plausibly be perverted on the other
hand into a defence of Nestorianism. Vid. also the Ed. Ben. on S.
Hilary, præf. p. xliii. who uses natura absolutely for our
Lord’s Divinity, as contrasted to the dispensatio, and
divides His titles into naturalia and
assumpta.. And this difference divine Scripture
recognises, saying concerning the creatures, ‘The earth is full
of Thy creation,’ and ‘the creation itself groaneth
together and travaileth together Ps. civ. 24. LXX.; Rom. viii.
22.;’ and in
the Apocalypse it says, ‘And the third part of the creatures in
the sea died which had life;’ as also Paul says, ‘Every
creature of God is good, and nothing is to be refused if it be received
with thanksgiving Rev. viii. 9; 1 Tim. iv.
4.;’ and in the
book of Wisdom it is written, ‘Having ordained man through Thy
wisdom, that he should have dominion over the creatures which Thou hast
made Wisd. ix. 2..’ And these, being creatures, are also
said to be created, as we may further hear from the Lord, who says,
‘He who created them, made them male and female Matt. xix. 4. (ὁ κτίσας).;’ and from Moses in the Song, who
writes, ‘Ask now of the days that are past, which were before
thee since the day that God created man upon the earth, and from the
one side of heaven unto the other Deut. iv. 32..’ And
Paul in Colossians, ‘Who is the Image of the Invisible God, the
Firstborn of every creature, for in Him were all things created that
are in heaven, and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether
they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers; all things
were created through Him, and for Him, and He is before all Col. i.
15–17.’