Chapter
XXIX.—Marcion Forbids Marriage. Tertullian Eloquently Defends It
as Holy, and Carefully Discriminates Between Marcion’s Doctrine
and His Own Montanism.
The flesh is not, according to Marcion, immersed
in the water of the sacrament, unless it be
2673
in
virginity, widowhood, or celibacy, or has purchased by divorce a title
to baptism, as if even generative impotents
2674
did not all receive their flesh from nuptial union. Now, such a scheme
as this must no doubt involve the proscription of marriage. Let
us see, then, whether it be a just one: not as if we
aimed at destroying the
happiness of sanctity, as do certain Nicolaitans in their maintenance
of lust and luxury, but as those who have come to the knowledge of
sanctity, and pursue it and prefer it, without detriment, however, to
marriage; not as if we superseded a bad thing by a good, but only a
good thing by a better. For we do not reject marriage, but simply
refrain from it.
2675
Nor do we prescribe
sanctity
2676
as the rule, but
only recommend it, observing it as a good, yea, even the better state,
if each man uses it carefully
2677
according to his
ability; but at the same time earnestly vindicating marriage, whenever
hostile attacks are made against it is a polluted thing, to the
disparagement of the Creator. For He bestowed His blessing on matrimony
also, as on an honourable estate, for the increase of the human race;
as He did indeed on the whole of His creation,
2678
for wholesome and good uses. Meats and drinks are not on this account
to be condemned, because, when served up with too exquisite a
daintiness, they conduce to gluttony; nor is raiment to be blamed,
because, when too costlily adorned, it becomes inflated with vanity and
pride. So, on the same principle, the estate of matrimony is not to be
refused, because, when enjoyed without moderation, it is fanned into a
voluptuous flame. There is a great difference between a cause and a
fault,
2679
between a state and
its excess. Consequently it is not an institution of this nature
that is to be blamed, but the extravagant use of it; according to the
judgment of its founder Himself, who not only said, “Be fruitful,
and multiply,”
2680
but also,
“Thou shalt not commit adultery,” and, “Thou shalt
not covet thy neighbour’s wife;”
2681
and who threatened with death the unchaste, sacrilegious, and monstrous
abomination both of adultery and unnatural sin with man and
beast.
2682
Now, if any
limitation is set to marrying—such as the spiritual
rule,
2683
which prescribes but one marriage under the
Christian obedience,
2684
maintained by the
authority of the Paraclete,
2685
—it will be
His prerogative to fix the limit Who had once been diffuse in His
permission; His to gather, Who once scattered; His to cut down the
tree, Who planted it; His to reap the harvest, Who sowed the seed; His
to declare, “It remaineth that they who have wives be as though
they had none,”
2686
Who once said,
“Be fruitful, and multiply;” His the end to Whom belonged
the beginning. Nevertheless, the tree is not cut down as if it deserved
blame; nor is the corn reaped, as if it were to be condemned,—but
simply because their time is come. So likewise the state of matrimony
does not require the hook and scythe of sanctity, as if it were evil;
but as being ripe for its discharge, and in readiness for that sanctity
which will in the long run bring it a plenteous crop by its
reaping. For this leads me to remark of Marcion’s god, that
in reproaching marriage as an evil and unchaste thing, he is really
prejudicing the cause of that very sanctity which he seems to
serve. For he destroys the material on which it subsists; if
there is to be no marriage, there is no sanctity. All proof of
abstinence is lost when excess is impossible; for sundry things have
thus their evidence in their contraries. Just as “strength
is made perfect in weakness,”
2687
so likewise is
continence made manifest by the permission to marry. Who indeed will be
called continent, if that be taken away which gives him the opportunity
of pursuing a life of continence? What room for temperance in appetite
does famine give? What repudiation of ambitious projects does poverty
afford? What bridling of lust can the eunuch merit? To put a
complete stop, however, to the sowing of the human race, may, for aught
I know, be quite consistent for Marcion’s most good and excellent
god. For how could he desire the salvation of man, whom he
forbids to be born, when he takes away that institution from which his
birth arises? How will he find any one on whom to set the mark of his
goodness, when he suffers him not to come into existence? How is it
possible to love him whose origin he hates? Perhaps he is afraid of a
redundant population, lest he should be weary in liberating so many;
lest he should have to make many heretics; lest Marcionite parents
should produce too many noble disciples of Marcion. The cruelty of
Pharaoh, which slew its victims at their birth, will not prove to be
more inhuman in comparison.
2688
For while he
destroyed lives, our heretic’s god refuses to give them: the one
removes from life, the other admits none to it. There is no
difference in either as to their homicide—man is slain by both of
them; by the former just after birth, by the latter as yet unborn.
Thanks should we owe thee, thou
god of our heretic, hadst thou only
checked
2689
the dispensation of
the Creator in uniting male and female; for from such a union indeed
has thy Marcion been born! Enough, however, of Marcion’s
god, who is shown to have absolutely no existence at all, both by our
definitions
2690
of the one only
Godhead, and the condition of his attributes.
2691
The whole course, however, of this little work aims directly at this
conclusion. If, therefore, we seem to anybody to have achieved
but little result as yet, let him reserve his expectations, until we
examine the very Scripture which Marcion quotes.
2673
Free from all
matrimonial impurity.
2674
Spadonibus. This
word is more general in sense than
eunuch
, embracing such as are
impotent both by nature and by castration, White and Riddle’s
Lat. Dict. s.v.
2675
Tertullian’s
Montanism
appears here.
2676
i.e., abstinence from
marriage.
2677
Sectando. [This,
indeed, seems to be a fair statement of Patristic doctrine concerning
marriage. As to our author’s variations see Kaye, p.
378.]
2678
Universum
conditionis.
2679
Causa
in its
proper sense is, “that through which anything takes place;”
its just and normal state, therefore.
Culpa
is the derangement
of the cause; some flaw in it.
2680
Gen. i. 28
.
2681
Ex. xx. 14, 17
.
2682
Lev. xx. 10, 13, 15
.
2683
Ratio.
2684
In fide. Tertullian
uses (
De Pud
. 18) “ante fidem” as synonymous
with
ante baptismum
; similarly “post
fidem.”
2685
[Bad as this is, does
it argue the lapse of our author as at this time complete?]
2686
1 Cor. vii. 29
.
2687
2 Cor. xii. 9
.
2688
This is the force of
the
erit
instead of the past tense.
2689
Isses in, i.e.,
obstitisses,
check
or
resist
, for then Marcion
would, of course, not have been born: the common text has
esses in
.
2690
Tertullian has
discussed these “definitions” in chap. ii. vii., and the
“conditions” from chap. viii. onward. He will
“examine the Scripture” passages in books iv. and v.
Fr. Junius.
2691
Statuum.