In the following year (Indict. XV.,
a.d. 596–7) John Jejunator died, and was
succeeded by Cyriacus, to whom Gregory wrote on receiving his synodical
letter, addressing him in a friendly tone (Ep. 4), but urging in
the course of his letter the rejection of the offensive title. He
wrote again (Ep. 31) especially on the subject, still
courteously, but pressing the matter strongly. To the emperor we
find two letters; the first (Ep. 6) approving of the appointment
of Cyriacus, but without any allusion to the burning question; the
second (Ep. 33), after receiving one from the emperor, in which
the desire had been expressed that the emissaries of the new patriarch
should be honourably received at Rome. To this request Gregory
replies that he has so received them, and admitted them to communion
with him, hoping for the best; but that his own representatives at
Constantinople would by no means be allowed to communicate with
Cyriacus, unless the title were renounced. The emperor had said
that the matter was a frivolous one. “Yes (says Gregory)
the title is indeed frivolous, but its meaning and its consequences are
serious;” and he repeals his continual assertion that whosoever
assumes it is the precursor of Antichrist. In this year also he
continued his
efforts
to induce the patriarchs Anastasius and Eulogius to join him in his
protest. Anastasius, it seems, had not, like Eulogius, ignored
the subject in his reply to the letter that had been addressed to both,
but had said that in his opinion the matter was of little moment and
not worth making a disturbance about; at the same time addressing
Gregory in flattering terms. Gregory, in his reply (Ep.
27), which is somewhat ironical, insists again. To Eulogius also
he writes again (Ep. 40), deprecating the too deferential manner
in which he had been addressed by this patriarch, and setting forth his
view of the oneness of the three sees. The offensive title itself
is not in this letter specifically referred to. There is also a
second letter to the two patriarchs jointly, explaining what had been
done so far since the accession of Cyriacus, and reiterating his
protest against allowance of the title. In the succeeding year
(Lib. VIII., Indict. I., a.d.
597–8) there is again a letter (Ep. 30) to Eulogius, who
appears to have written a third time to Gregory, at length alluding to
the title so far as to say that he did not now use proud titles in
addressing certain persons, but still apparently not prepared to take
any action. As if to make up for such inaction, he had seemingly
been profuse in his compliments to Gregory, using the expression,
“as thou hast commanded,” and calling him “Universal
Pope.” Such language Gregory, in reply, earnestly protests
against, disclaiming for himself, as much as for any other bishop, the
name of Universal. In the following year (Lib. IX.,
Indict. II., a.d. 598–9) we find
two letters; one of which is an encyclical one (Ep. 68), to
Eusebius of Thessalonica and other Eastern bishops, in view of a synod
about to be held at Constantinople, warning them against being cajoled
there into assenting to the title, and threatening them with
excommunication in case of their complying. From the second
letter assigned to this year, which is again to Eulogius (Ep.
78), it would seem that the synod at Constantinople had been held, and
that Eulogius himself had been there, though what had been done does
not appear. The letter is in reply to one which had been received
with reference to a different subject from Eulogius; and Gregory
complains that the latter had still said nothing about the most
important subject of all, namely the title. He supposes Eulogius
to be waiting till he himself shall take decided action; and he
accounts for his own apparent delay by saying that he had been
unwilling to be himself the immediate author of schism. It seems
as if he had felt at a loss what to do. His remonstrances with
Cyriacus and the emperor had been entirely unavailing; he had failed to
move the two great Eastern patriarchs, or the bishops of the East
generally, to take up the question; and he shrank from so serious a
step as breaking off communion with the whole Eastern Church. And
so matters appear to have rested. We find no further epistle on
the subject till four years later (Lib. XIII, Indict.
VI., a.d. 602–3), when in a short letter
(Ep. 40) to Cyriacus, with whom he appears to be still in
communion, he urges him once more to give up the title. There are
in the same year two letters, and one in the previous one (XII. 50), as
well as two (X., 35, 39) in the third indiction, to Eulogius, in which
the subject is not alluded to.