Many of the bishops who were making their way to
the great festival met at Tyre. The Arian element was very strong.
Eusebius of Nicomedia, Narcissus, Maris, Theognis, Patrophilus, George,
now bishop of Laodicea, are all familiar names. Ursacius and Valens,
‘young p. 107:
Euseb. V. C. iv. 43, calls them ‘the fairest of
God’s youthful flock.’ The Council of Sardica in 343
describes them as ‘ungodly and foolish youths,’ Hil.
Frag. ii., cf. pp. 120, 122. both in years and in mind’ make
their first entrance on the stage of ecclesiastical intrigue; Eusebius
of Cæsarea headed a large body of ‘conservative’
malcontents: in the total number of perhaps 150, the friends of
Athanasius were outnumbered by nearly two to one. (See Gwatkin’s
note, p. 85, Hefele ii. 17, Eng Tra.) Eusebius of Cæsarea
took the chair (yet see D.C.B. ii. 316b). The proceedings of
the Council were heated and disorderly; promiscuous accusations were
flung from side to side; the president himself was charged by an
excited Egyptian Confessor with having sacrificed to idols (p. 104, n.
2), while against Athanasius every possible charge was raked up. The
principal one was that of harshness and violence. Callinicus, bishop of
Pelusium, according to a later story Soz. ii.
25. But Callinicus was a Meletian all along: pp. 132, 137,
517., had taken up the
cause of Ischyras, and been deposed by Athanasius in consequence. A
certain Mark had been appointed to supersede him, and he had been
subjected to military force. Certain Meletian bishops who had refused
to communicate with Athanasius on account of his irregular election,
had been beaten and imprisoned. A document from Alexandria testified
that the Churches were emptied on account of the strong popular feeling
against these proceedings. The number of witnesses, and the evident
readiness of the majority of bishops to believe the worst against him,
inspired Athanasius with profound misgivings as to his chance of
obtaining justice. He had in vain objected to certain bishops as
biassed judges; when it was decided to investigate the case of Ischyras
on the spot, the commission of six was chosen from among the very
persons challenged (p. 138). Equally unsuccessful was the protest of
the Egyptian bishops against the credit of the Meletian witnesses (p.
140). But on one point the accusers walked into a trap. The ‘hand
of Arsenius’ was produced, and naturally made a deep impression
(Thdt. H. E. i. 30). But Athanasius was ready. ‘Did you
know Arsenius personally?’ ‘Yes’ is the eager reply
from many sides. Promptly Arsenius is ushered in alive, wrapped up in a
cloak. The Synod expected an explanation of the way he had lost his
hand. Athanasius turned up his
cloak and shewed that one hand at least was there. There was a moment
of suspense, artfully managed by Athanasius. Then the other hand was
exposed, and the accusers were requested to point out whence the third
had been cut off (Socr. i. 29). This was too much for John Arcaph, who
precipitately fled (so Socr., he seems to have gone to Egypt with the
couriers mentioned below, cf. p. 142). But the Eusebians were made of
sterner stuff: the whole affair was a piece of magic; or there had been
an attempt to murder Arsenius, who had hid himself from fear. At any
rate Athanasius must not be allowed to clear himself so easily.
Accordingly, in order partly to gain time and partly to get up a more
satisfactory case, they prevailed on Count Dionysius, in the face of
strong remonstrances from Athanasius (p. 138), to despatch a commission
of enquiry to the Mareotis in order to ascertain the real facts about
Ischyras. The nature of the commission may be inferred, firstly, from
its composition, four strong Arians and two (Theodore of Heraclea, and
Macedonius of Mopsuestia) reactionaries; secondly, from the fact that
they took Ischyras with them, but left Macarius behind in custody;
thirdly, from the fact that couriers were sent to Egypt with four
days’ start, and with an urgent message to the Meletians to
collect at once in as large numbers as possible at Irene, so as to
impress the commissioners with the importance of the Meletian community
at that place. The Egyptian bishops present at Tyre handed in
strongly-worded protests to the Council, and to Count Dionysius, who
received also a weighty remonstrance from the respected Alexander,
Bishop of Thessalonica. This drew forth from him an energetic protest
to the Eusebians (p. 142 sq.) against the composition of the
commission. His protest was not, however, enforced in any practical
way, and the Egyptians thereupon appealed to the Emperor (ib.).
Athanasius himself escaped in an open boat with four of his bishops,
and found his way to Constantinople, where he arrived on October 30.
The Emperor was out riding when he was accosted by one of a group of
pedestrians. He could scarcely credit his eyes and the assurance of his
attendants that the stranger was none other than the culprit of Tyre.
Much annoyed at his appearance, he refused all communication; but the
persistency of Athanasius and the reasonableness of his demand
prevailed. The Emperor wrote to Jerusalem to summon to his presence all
who had been at the Council of Tyre (pp. 105, 145).