But this has made it inevitable that many matters
are regarded in one way in the notes of Newman, and in quite another
where the present editor speaks for himself. What the great Cardinal
says of his ‘Historical Sketches’ (Preface to vol. ii.)
holds good to a large extent of his expositions of Athanasius.
‘Though mainly historical, they are in their form and character
polemical, as being directed against certain Protestant ideas and
opinions.’ The aim of the present editor has been throughout exclusively
historical. He has regarded any polemical purpose as foreign to the
spirit in which this series was undertaken, and moreover as fated in
the long run to defeat its own aim. Whatever results may ultimately be
reaped from the field of patristic studies, whether practical,
dogmatic, or controversial, they must be resolutely postponed or rather
ignored, pending the application of strict method to the criticism and
interpretation of the texts, and to the reconstruction of the history
whether of the life or of the doctrine of the Church. For the latter
purpose, ‘lucifera experimenta, non fructifera
quærenda.’ To follow this method, without concealing, but
without obtruding, his personal convictions, has been the endeavour of
the present editor. That he has succeeded, it is not for him to claim:
but his work has been in this respect disinterested, and he ventures to
hope that readers of all opinions will at least recognise in it
‘un livre de bonne foy.’