“Next, I may reasonably turn to those who
divide and cut to pieces and destroy that most sacred doctrine of the
Church of God, the Divine Monarchy By the
Monarchy is meant the doctrine that the Second and Third Persons in the
Ever-blessed Trinity are ever to be referred in our thoughts to the
First as the Fountain of Godhead, vid. §15. note 9, and §19,
note 6. It is one of the especial senses in which God is said to be
one. Cf. Orat. iii. §15. vid. also iv. §1. ‘The
Father is union, ἕνωσις,’
says S. Greg. Naz. ‘from whom and unto whom are the
others.’ Orat. 42. 15. also Orat. 20. 7. and Epiph.
Hær. 57. 5. Tertullian, before Dionysius, uses the word
Monarchia, which Praxeas had perverted into a kind of Unitarianism or
Sabellianism, in Prax. 3. Irenæus too wrote on the
Monarchy, i.e. against the doctrine that God is the author of evil.
Eus. Hist. v. 20. [see S. Iren. fragment 33, Ante-Nic.
Lib.] And before him was Justin’s work de Monarchia, where
the word is used in opposition to Polytheism. The Marcionites, whom
Dionysius presently mentions, are also specified in the above extract
by Athan. vid. also Cyril. Hier. Cat. xvi. 3. Epiphanius says
that their three origins were God, the Creator, and the evil spirit.
Hær. 42, 3. or as Augustine says, the good, the just, and
the wicked, which may be taken to mean nearly the same thing.
Hær. 22. The Apostolical Canons denounce those who baptize
into Three Unoriginate; vid. also Athan. Tom. ad Antioch. 5.
Naz. Orat. 20. 6. Basil denies τρεῖς
ἀρχικαὶ
ὑποστάσεις, de Sp. S. 38. which is a Platonic
phrase., making it as it
were three powers and partitive subsistences And so
Dionysius Alex. in a fragment preserved by S. Basil, ‘If because
the subsistences are three, they say that they are partitive,
μεμερισμένας, still three there are, though these persons dissent, or
they utterly destroy the Divine Trinity.’ de Sp. S. n. 72.
Athan. expresses the same more distinctly, οὐ τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
μεμερισμένας, Expos. Fid. §2. In S. Greg. Naz. we
find ἀμέριστος
ἐν
μεμερισμένοις
ἡ θεότης.
Orat. 31. 14. Elsewhere for μεμ. he substitutes
ἀπεῤ&
191·ηγμένας. Orat. 20. 6. ἀπεξενωμένας
ἀλλήλων καὶ
διεσπασμένας. Orat. 23. 6. as infr. ξένας
ἀλλήλων
παντάπασι
κεχωρισμένας. The passage in the text comes into question in the
controversy about the ἐξ
ὑποστάσεως ἢ
οὐσίας of the
Nicene Creed, of which infr. on the Creed itself in Eusebius’s
Letter. and
god-heads three. I am told that some among you who are catechists and
teachers of the Divine Word, take the lead in this tenet, who are
diametrically opposed, so to speak, to Sabellius’s opinions; for
he blasphemously says that the Son is the Father, and the Father the
Son, but they in some sort preach three Gods, as dividing the sacred
Monad into three subsistences foreign to each other and utterly
separate. For it must needs be that with the God of the Universe, the
Divine Word is united, and the Holy Ghost must repose ἐμφιλοχωρεῖν
and habitate in God; thus in one as in a summit, I mean the God of the
Universe, must the Divine Triad The
word τριὰς, usually
translated Trinity, is first used by Theophilus, ad Autol. ii.
15. Gibbon remarks that the doctrine of ‘a numerical rather than
a generical unity,’ which has been explicitly put forth by the
Latin Church, is favoured by the Latin language; τριὰς seems to excite the idea of substance, trinitas of
qualities.’ ch. 21. note 74. It is certain that the Latin view of
the sacred truth, when perverted, becomes Sabellianism; and that the
Greek, when perverted, becomes Arianism; and we find Arius arising in
the East, Sabellius in the West. It is also certain that the word
Trinitas is properly abstract; and expresses τριὰς or
‘a three,’ only in an ecclesiastical sense. But Gibbon does
not seem to observe that Unitas is abstract as well as Trinitas; and
that we might just as well say in consequence, that the Latins held an
abstract unity or a unity of qualities, while the Greeks by
μονὰς taught the doctrine of ‘a one’ or a numerical
unity. ‘Singularitatem hanc dico (says S. Ambrose), quod
Græce μονότης dicitur; singularitas ad personam pertinet, unitas ad
naturam.’ de Fid. v. 1. It is important, however, to
understand, that ‘Trinity’ does not mean the state
or condition of being three, as humanity is the condition of
being man, but is synonymous with three persons. Humanity does
not exist and cannot be addressed, but the Holy Trinity is a three, or
a unity which exists in three. Apparently from not considering this,
Luther and Calvin objected to the word Trinity, ‘It is a common
prayer,’ says Calvin: ‘Holy Trinity, one God, have mercy on
us. It displeases me, and savours throughout of barbarism.’
Ep. ad Polon. p. 796. be gathered up and
brought together. For it is the
doctrine of the presumptuous Marcion, to sever and divide the Divine
Monarchy into three origins,—a devil’s teaching, not that
of Christ’s true disciples and lovers of the Saviour’s
lessons. For they know well that a Triad is preached by divine
Scripture, but that neither Old Testament nor New preaches three Gods.
Equally must one censure those who hold the Son to be a work, and
consider that the Lord has come into being, as one of things which
really came to be; whereas the divine oracles witness to a generation
suitable to Him and becoming, but not to any fashioning or making. A
blasphemy then is it, not ordinary, but even the highest, to say that
the Lord is in any sort a handiwork. For if He came to be Son, once He
was not; but He was always, if (that is) He be in the Father, as He
says Himself, and if the Christ be Word and Wisdom and Power (which, as
ye know, divine Scripture says), and these attributes be powers of God.
If then the Son came into being, once these attributes were not;
consequently there was a time, when God was without them; which is most
absurd. And why say more on these points to you, men full of the Spirit
and well aware of the absurdities which come to view from saying that
the Son is a work? Not attending, as I consider, to this circumstance,
the authors of this opinion have entirely missed the truth, in
explaining, contrary to the sense of divine and prophetic Scripture in
the passage, the words, ‘The Lord created me a beginning of His
ways unto His works Prov. viii.
22..’ For the sense
of ‘He created,’ as ye know, is not one, for we must
understand ‘He created’ in this place, as ‘He set
over the works made by Him,’ that is, ‘made by the Son
Himself.’ And ‘He created’ here must not be taken for
‘made,’ for creating differs from making. ‘Is not He
thy Father that hath bought thee? hath He not made thee and created
thee Deut. xxxii.
6.?’says Moses in his great song in
Deuteronomy. And one may say to them, O reckless men, is He a work, who
is ‘the First-born of every creature, who is born from the womb
before the morning star Col. i. 15, and Ps. cx.
3.,’ who said, as
Wisdom, ‘Before all the hills He begets me Prov. viii.
25.?’ And in many passages of the divine
oracles is the Son said to have been γεγεννῆσθαι generated, but
nowhere to have γεγονέναι come into being;
which manifestly convicts those of misconception about the Lord’s
generation, who presume to call His divine and ineffable generation a
making γεγονέναι. Neither then may we divide into three
Godheads the wonderful and divine Monad; nor disparage with the name of
‘work’ the dignity and exceeding majesty of the Lord; but
we must believe in God the Father Almighty, and in Christ Jesus His
Son, and in the Holy Ghost, and hold that to the God of the universe
the Word is united This
extract discloses to us (in connexion with the passages from Dionysius
Alex. here and in the de Sent. D.) a remarkable anticipation of
the Arian controversy in the third century. 1. It appears that the very
symbol of ἦν ὅτε οὐκ
ἦν, ‘once He was not,’
was asserted or implied; vid. also the following extract from Origen,
§27. and Origen Periarchon, iv. 28. where mention is also
made of the ἐξ οὐκ
ὄντων, ‘out of
nothing,’ which was the Arian symbol in opposition to ‘of
the substance.’ Allusions are made besides, to ‘the Father
not being always Father,’ de Sent. D. 15. and ‘the
Word being brought to be by the true Word, and Wisdom by the true
Wisdom;’ ibid. 25. 2. The same special text is used in defence of
the heresy, and that not at first sight an obvious one, which is found
among the Arians, Prov. viii. 22. 3. The same texts were
used by the Catholics, which occur in the Arian controversy.
e.g. Deut. xxxii. 6. against Prov.
viii. 22. and such as Ps. cx. 3. Prov. viii. 25. and the two John x.
30. and xiv. 10. 4. The same Catholic symbols and statements are found,
e.g. ‘begotten not made,’ ‘one in essence,’
‘Trinity,’ ἀδιαίρετον,
ἄναρχον,
ἀειγενες, ‘light from light,’ &c. Much might be said on
this circumstance, as forming part of the proof of the very early date
of the development and formation of the Catholic theology, which we are
at first sight apt to ascribe to the 4th and 5th centuries. [But see
Introd. to de Sent. Dion.]. For ‘I,’
says He, ‘and the Father are one;’ and, ‘I in the
Father and the Father in Me.’ For thus both the Divine Triad, and
the holy preaching of the Monarchy, will be preserved.”