to what I do say, and say very often; and so takes occasion, or rather makes an occasion, to
charge me before the world, with telling a manifest untruth, (p. 15. d.)
Again, Mr. W. in answering my argument concerning brotherly love, (p. 70. e. 71. a.)
represents me as arguing, “That in the exercise of christian love described in the gospel,
there is such an union of hearts, as there cannot be of a saint to an unsanctified man.” Which
is a thing I never said, and is quite contrary to the sentiments which I have abundantly de-
clared. I indeed speak of that brotherly love, as what cannot be of a saint to one that is not
apprehended and judged to be sanctified. But that notion of a peculiar love, which cannot
be to an unsanctified man—or without the reality of holiness in the person beloved—is what
I ever abhorred, and have borne a most loud and open and large testimony against, again
and again, from the press, 414 and did so in the preface to that very book which Mr. W.
writes against.
In p. 74. a. b. Mr. W. represents me as supposing, that in the sacrament of the Lord’s
supper, both the covenanting parties, viz. Christ and the communicant, seal to the truth of
the communicant’s faith; or that both seal to this as true, that the communicant does receive
Christ. Whereas, by me, no such thing was ever thought; nor is any thing said that has such
an aspect. What I say, is very plain and express, (p. 75.) “That Christ by his minister professes
his part of the covenant, presents himself, and professes the willingness of his heart to be
theirs who receive him. That on the other hand, the communicant in receiving the offered
symbols, professes his part in the covenant, and the willingness of his heart to receive Christ
who is offered.” How different is this from both parties sealing to the truth of the commu-
nicant’s faith!
In p. 76, 77, and 80, he greatly misrepresents my argument from . “Let a man examine
himself,” &c. as though I supposed, the Greek word translated examine, must necessarily
imply an examination to approbation; that it signifies to approve; and that a man’s examin-
ation must mean his approving himself to himself to be sanctified. This representation he
makes over and over, and builds his answer to the argument upon it; and in opposition to
this, he says, (p. 77. c.) “Wherever the word means to examine to approbation, it is not used
in its natural sense, but metonymically.” Whereas, there is not the least foundation for such
a representation: no such thing is said or suggested by me, as if I supposed that the meaning
of the word is to approve, or to examine to approbation. What I say is, that it properly signifies
proving or trying a thing, whether it be true and of the right sort. (p. 77. d.) And, in the same
place, I expressly speak of the word (in the manner Mr. W. does) as not used in its natural
sense, but metonymically, when it is used to signify approve. So that Mr. W.‘s representation
is not only diverse from, but contrary to, what I say. Indeed I suppose (as well I may) that
414 Marks of a Work of the True Spirit, p. 101, 102.103,104. Thoughts on the Revival of Religion, from p. 292
to 303. Nature of Religious Affections, p. 85-87. Preface to Inquiry into Qualifications for Communion, p. 5.
1969
SECTION I. Method of disputing.