scandalous apostacy. Supposing then the presence of Judas at the Lord’s supper, this affords
no consequence in favour of what I oppose.
Answ. 3. If they with whom I have to do in this controversy, are not contented with the
answers already given, and think there is a remaining difficulty in this matter lying against
my scheme, I will venture to tell them, that this difficulty lies full as hard against their own
scheme; and if there be any strength at all in the argument, it is to all intents of the same
strength against the need of those qualifications which they themselves suppose to be neces-
sary in order to an approach to the Lord’s table. For although they do not think renewing
saving grace necessary, yet they suppose moral seriousness or (as they variously speak)
moral sincerity in religion to be necessary. They suppose it to be requisite, that persons
should have some kind of serious principle and view in coming to the Lord’s table; some
intention of subjecting themselves to Christ, and of seeking and serving him, in general;
and in particular some religious end in coming to the sacramental supper, some religious
respect to Christ in it. But now did not Christ at that time perfectly know, that Judas had
none of these things? He knew he had nothing of sincerity in the christian religion, or of
regard to Christ in that ordinance, of any sort whatsoever; he knew, that Satan had entered
into him and filled his heart, and that he was then cherishing in himself a malignant spirit
against his Master, excited by the reproof Christ had lately given him, (compare John xii.
8.. with Matt. xxvi. 8-16.. and Mark xiv. 4-11..) and that he had already formed a traitorous,
murderous design against him, and was now in the prosecution of that bloody design, having
actually just before been to the chief priests, and agreed with them to betray him for thirty
pieces of silver. (See Matt. xxvi. 14, 15, 16.. Mark xiv. 10, 11.. Luke xxii. 3-6.. and John xiii.
2..) Christ knew these things, and knew that Judas was utterly unqualified for the holy sac-
rament of the Lord’s supper; though it had not yet been made known to the church, or the
disciples.—Therefore it concerns those on the contrary part in this controversy, to find out
some solution of this difficulty, as much as it does me; and they will find they have as much
need to take refuge in the solution already given, in one or other of the two preceding answers
to this objection.
469
By the way I would observe, that Christ’s not excluding Judas from the passover, under
these circumstances, knowing him to be thus unqualified, without so much as moral sincerity,
&c. is another thing that effectually enervates all the strength of the objection against me,
from the passover. For Judas did not only in common with others fall under God’s strict
command, in the law of Moses, to keep this feast, without any exception of his case there
to be found; but Christ himself, with his own hand, gave him the sop, a part of the paschal
feast; even although at the same instant he had in view the man’s secret wickedness and
hypocrisy, the traitorous design which was then in his heart, and the horrid conspiracy with
the chief priests, which he had already entered into, and was now prosecuting. This was
then in Christ’s mind, and he intimated it to him, at the same moment when he gave him
1846
OBJ. VII. Case of Judas.