(vide Du Cange). They granted εἰρενικαὶ, or letters dimissory, which country presbyters
were forbidden to do. They had also the honorary privilege (τιμώμενοι ) of assisting at the
celebration of the Holy Eucharist in the mother city church, which country presbyters had
not (Conc. Ancyr. can. xiii.; Neo-Cæsar. can. xiv.; Antioch, can. x.; St. Basil M. Epist. 181;
Rab. Maur. De Instit. Cler. i. 5, etc. etc.). They were held therefore to have power of ordina-
tion, but to lack jurisdiction, save subordinately. And the actual ordination of a presbyter
by Timotheus, a chorepiscopus, is recorded (Pallad., Hist. Lausiac. 106).
22
In the West, i.e. chiefly in Gaul, the order appears to have prevailed more widely, to
have usurped episcopal functions without due subordination to the diocesans, and to have
been also taken advantage of by idle or worldly diocesans. In consequence it seems to have
aroused a strong feeling of hostility, which showed itself, first in a series of papal bulls,
condemning them; headed, it is true, by two forged letters respectively of Damasus I. and
Leo. M. (of which the latter is merely an interpolated version of Conc. Hispal. II. a.d. 619,
can. 7, adding chorepiscopi to presbyteri, of which latter the council really treats), but con-
tinuing in a more genuine form, from Leo III. down to Pope Nicholas I. (to Rodolph,
Archbishop of Bourges, a.d. 864); the last of whom, however, takes the more moderate line
of affirming chorepiscopi to be really bishops, and consequently refusing to annul their or-
dinations of presbyters and deacons (as previous popes had done), but orders them to keep
within canonical limits; and secondly, in a series of conciliar decrees, Conc. Ratispon. a.d.
800, in Capit. lib. iv. c. 1, Paris. a.d. 829, lib. i.c. 27; Meld. a.d. 845, can. 44; Metens. a.d. 888,
can. 8, and Capitul. v. 168, vi. 119, vii. 187, 310, 323, 324, annulling all episcopal acts of
chorepiscopi, and ordering them to be repeated by “true” bishops; and finally forbidding
all further appointments of chorepiscopi at all.
That chorepiscopi as such—i.e. omitting the cases of reconciled or vacant bishops above
mentioned, of whose episcopate of course no question is made—were at first truly bishops
both in East and West, appears almost certain, both from their name and functions, and
even from the arguments of their strong opponents just spoken of. If nothing more could
be urged against them, than that the Council of Neo-Cæsarea compared them to the Seventy
disciples, that the Council of Antioch authorises their consecration by a single bishop, and
that they actually were so consecrated (the Antiochene decree mightmean merely nomination
by the word γίνεσθαι, but the actual history seems to rule the term to intend consecration,
and the [one] exceptional case of a chorepiscopus recorded [Actt. Episc. Cenoman. ap. Du
Cange] in late times to have been ordained by three bishops [in order that he might be a full
bishop] merely proves the general rule to the contrary)—and that they were consecrated
for “villages,” contrary to canon,—then they certainly were bishops. And Pope Nicholas
expressly says that they were so. Undoubtedly they ceased to be so in the East, and were
practically merged in archdeacons in the West.
For the second opinion, its great champion, Thomassinus shall speak.
74
Excursus on the Chorepiscopi.