Eusebius, and the Greeks in general, write the name Νοου€τος (though in Bk. VII. chap. 8, below, Dionysius writes
Νοουατι€νος). Socrates has the form Ναυ€τος, which appears also in some mss. of
Eusebius. Cyprian and the Latins write the name Novatianus. Lardner, in
a note on chap. 47 of his Credibility, argues with great force
for the correctness of the name Novatus, while Heinichen and others
maintain that Novatianus is the right form. The name
Novatiani, Νοουατιανοί, which was given to his followers, is urged with some
reason by Lardner as an argument for the shorter form of the name. But
even if his opinion is correct, the name Novatian is too long
established to be displaced, and serves to distinguish him from the
Carthaginian presbyter Novatus. The schism of Novatian was only one of
the outcrops of the old strife between lax and strict discipline in the
Church, the strife which had shown itself in connection with Montanism
and also between Callistus and Hippolytus (see above, chap. 21, note
3). But in the present case the immediate cause of the trouble was the
treatment of the lapsed. The terrible Decian persecution had naturally
caused many to deny the faith, but afterward, when the stress was past,
they repented and desired to be readmitted to the Church. The question
became a very serious one, and opinions were divided, some advocating
their acceptance after certain prescribed penances, others their
continued exclusion. The matter caused a great deal of discussion,
especially in Rome and Carthage. The trouble came to a head in Rome,
when Cornelius, who belonged to the lax party, was chosen bishop in the
year 251, after the see had been vacant for more than a year. The
stricter party at once aroused to action and chose Novatian, the leader
of the party, opposition bishop. He had been made a presbyter by the
bishop Fabian, and occupied a very prominent position in the Roman
Church. He seems originally to have held less rigid notions in regard
to the treatment of the lapsed, but before the end of the persecution
he became very decided in his opposition to their absolution and
restoration. His position, as well as his ability and piety, made him
the natural leader of the party and the rival candidate for the
bishopric. He does not, however, seem to have desired to accept
consecration as an opposition bishop, but his party insisted. He
immediately sent the usual letters announcing the fact to the bishops
of the principal sees, to Carthage, Alexandria, and Rome. Cyprian at
once refused to recognize his appointment. Dionysius wrote to him
advising him to withdraw (see his epistle, quoted in chap. 45). But
Fabius of Antioch was inclined to take his side (see chap. 44,
§1). Novatian was excommunicated by the council mentioned just
below, and then founded an independent church, baptizing all who came
over to his side. We know nothing of his subsequent career (according
to the tradition of his followers, and also Socrates, H. E. IV.
28, he suffered martyrdom under Valerian), but his sect spread
throughout the East and West, and continued in existence until the
sixth century. Novatian was not at all heretical in doctrine. His work
upon the Trinity is both able and orthodox. His character was austere
and of unblemished purity (the account given by Cornelius below is a
gross misrepresentation, from the pen of an enemy) and his talents were
of a high order. But the tendency of the Church was toward a more
merciful treatment of the lapsed and of other sinners, and the stricter
methods advocated by him fell more and more into disfavor. Novatian was
quite a prolific writer. According to Jerome, de vir. ill. chap.
10, he wrote de Pascha, de Sabbato, de Circumcisione, de Sacerdote,
de Oratione, de Cibis Judaicis, de Instantia, de Attalo Multaque alia,
et de Trinitate grande Volumen. The de Cibis Judaicis and
the de Trinitate are still extant. The best edition of his works
is that of Jackson (London, 1728). An English translation is given in
the Ante-Nicene Fathers, V. 611–650. Novatian was the
author also of one of the epistles of the Roman clergy to Cyprian
(Ep. 30). Our contemporaneous sources for a knowledge of
Novatian and his schism are the epistles of Cyprian (some ten of them),
and the epistles of Dionysius and Cornelius, quoted by Eusebius in this
chapter and in chaps. 44 and 45.