Flavius Clemens was a cousin of Domitian, and his wife, Domitilla,
a niece of the emperor. They stood high in favor, and their two sons
were designated as heirs to the empire, while Flavius Clemens himself
was made Domitian’s colleague in the consulship. But immediately
afterward Clemens was put to death and Domitilla was banished.
Suetonius (Domit, chap. 15) accuses Clemens of
contemtissimæ inertiæ, and Dion Cassius (LXVII. 14) of
atheism (ἀθεότητος). These accusations are just such as heathen writers of
that age were fond of making against the Christians (compare, for
instance, Athenagoras’ Adv. Gent. chap. 4, and
Tertullian’s Apol. chap. 42). Accordingly it has been very
commonly held that both Flavius Clemens and Domitilla were Christians,
and were punished on that account. But early tradition makes only
Domitilla a Christian; and certainly if Clemens also—a man of
such high rank—had been a Christian, an early tradition to that
effect would be somewhere preserved. We must, therefore, conclude that
his offense was something else than Christianity. The very silence of
Christian tradition as to Clement is an argument for the truth of the
tradition in regard to Domitilla, and the heathen historians referred
to confirm its main points, though they differ in minor details. The
Acts of Martyrdom of Nereus and Achilles represent Domitilla as
the niece, not the wife, of Flavius Clemens, and Eusebius does the
same. More than that, while the heathen writers report that Domitilla
was banished to the island Pandeteria, these Acts, as well as
Eusebius and Jerome (Ep. adv. Eustachium, Migne’s ed.,
Ep. CVIII. 7), give the island of Pontia as the place of
banishment. Tillemont and other writers have therefore assumed that
there were two Domitillas,—aunt and niece,—one banished to
one island, the other to another. But this is very improbable, and it
is easier to suppose that there was but one Domitilla and but one
island, and that the discrepancies are due to carelessness or to the
mistakes of transcribers. Pandeteria and Pontia were two small islands
in the Mediterranean, just west of central Italy, and were very
frequently employed by the Roman emperors as places of exile for
prisoners.