52. Further, if, in confessing Father and Son, we
spoke of two beginnings or two Gods as Marcion and Valentinus Supr. p. 167, note 7, and p. 307., or said that the Son had any other mode of
godhead, and was not the Image and Expression of the Father, as being
by nature born from Him, then He might be considered unlike; for such
essences are altogether unlike each other. But if we acknowledge that
the Father’s godhead is one and sole, and that of Him the Son is
the Word and Wisdom; and, as thus believing, are far from speaking of
two Gods, but understand the oneness of the Son with the Father to be,
not in likeness of their teaching, but according to essence and in
truth, and hence speak not of two Gods but of one God; there being but
one Form ἕνος
ὄντος εἴδους
θεότητος: for the word εἶδος, cf.
Orat. iii. 16 is generally applied to the Son, as in what
follows, and is synonymous [?] with hypostasis; but it is remarkable
that here it is almost synonymous with οὐσία or
φύσις. Indeed in one sense nature, substance, and hypostasis, are
all synonymous, i.e. as one and all denoting the Una Res, which is
Almighty God. The apparent confusion is useful as reminding us of this
great truth; vid. note 8, infr. of Godhead, as the Light is one and
the Radiance; (for this was seen by the Patriarch Jacob, as Scripture
says, ‘The sun rose upon him when the Form of God passed
by,’ Gen. xxxii. 31, LXX.); and beholding this, and
understanding of whom He was Son and Image, the holy Prophets say,
‘The Word of the Lord came to me;’ and recognising the
Father, who was beheld and revealed in Him, they made bold to say,
‘The God of our fathers hath appeared unto me, the God of
Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob’ (Exod. iii. 16); this being so, wherefore scruple we to
call Him coessential who is one with the Father, and appears as doth
the Father, according to likeness and oneness of godhead? For if, as
has been many times said, He has it not to be proper to the
Father’s essence, nor to resemble, as a Son, we may well scruple:
but if this be the illuminating and creative Power, specially proper to
the Father, without Whom He neither frames nor is known (for all things
consist through Him and in Him); wherefore, perceiving the fact, do we
decline to use the phrase conveying it? For what is it to be thus
connatural with the Father, but to be one in essence with Him? for God
attached not to Him the Son from without De
Decr. §31.,
as needing a servant; nor are the works on a level with the Creator,
and honoured as He is, or to be thought one with the Father. Or let a
man venture to make the distinction, that the sun and the radiance are
two lights, or different essences; or to say that the radiance accrued
to it over and above, and is not a simple and pure offspring from the
sun; such, that sun and radiance are two, but the light one, because
the radiance is an offspring from the Sun. But, whereas not more
divisible, nay less divisible is the nature [φύσις is here
(as the apodosis of the clause shows) as well as in the next section,
used as a somewhat more vague equivalent for οὐσία,
not, as Newman contends in an omitted note, for ‘person,’ a
use which is scarcely borne out by the (no doubt somewhat fluctuating)
senses of φύσις in the
passages quoted by him from Alexander (in Theod. H. E. i. 4, cf.
Origen’s use of οὐσία,
Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2) a) and Cyril c. Nest.
iii. p. 91. φύσις and
οὐσία
are nearly equivalent in the manifesto of Basil of
Ancyra, whom Ath. has in view here, see Epiph. Hær. 73.
12–22.] of
the Son towards the Father, and the godhead not accruing to the Son,
but the Father’s godhead being in the Son, so that he that hath
seen the Son hath seen the Father in Him; wherefore should not such a
one be called Coessential?