it might be mended in a great many respects. But however God’s altar may appear homely
to us, yet if we lift up our hand to mend it, we shall pollute it. Laws and institutions are
given for the general good, and not to avoid every particular inconvenience. And however
it may so happen, that sometimes inconveniences (real or imaginary) may attend the scheme
I have maintained; yet, I think, they are in no measure equal to the manifest conveniences
and happy tendencies of it, or to the palpable inconveniences and pernicious consequences
of the other.—I have already mentioned some things of this aspect, and would here briefly
observe some others.
Thus, the way of making such a difference between outward duties of morality, and
worship, and those great inward duties of our love of God and acceptance of Christ, that the
former must be visible, but that there need be no exhibition nor pretence of the latter, in order
to persons being admitted into the visible family of God; and that under a notion of the
latter being impossibilities, but the other being within men’s power; this, I think, has a direct
tendency to confirm in men an insensibility of the heinousness of unbelief and enmity against
God our Saviour, which are the source and sum of all wickedness. It tends to prevent their
coming under an humbling conviction of the greatness and utter inexcusableness of these
sins, which men must be brought to if ever they obtain salvation. Indeed it is a way that not
only has this tendency, but has actually and apparently this effect, and that to a great degree.
The effect of this method of proceeding in the churches in New England, which have
fallen into it, is actually this.—There are some that are received into these churches under
the notion of their being in the judgment of rational charity visible saints or professing saints,
who yet at the same time are actually open professors of heinous wickedness; I mean, the
wickedness of living in known impenitence and unbelief, the wickedness of living in enmity
against God, and in the rejection of Christ under the gospel. Or, which is the same thing,
they are such as freely and frequently acknowledge, that they do not profess to be as yet
born again, but look on themselves as really unconverted, as having never unfeignedly accep-
ted of Christ; and they do either explicitly or implicitly number themselves among those
that love not the Lord Jesus Christ; of whom the apostle says, let such be Anathema Maran-
atha! And accordingly it is known, all over the town where they live, that they make no
pretensions to any sanctifying grace already obtained; nor of consequence are they commonly
looked upon as any other than unconverted persons. Now, can this be judged the comely
order of the gospel? or shall God be supposed the author of such confusion?
In this way of church-proceeding, God’s own children and the true disciples of Christ
are obliged to receive those as their brethren, admit them to the communion of saints, and
embrace them in the highest acts of christian society, even in their great feast of love, where
they feed together on the body and blood of Christ, whom yet they have no reason to look
upon otherwise than as enemies of the cross of Christ, and haters of their heavenly Father
and dear Redeemer. For they make no pretension to any thing at all inconsistent with those
1875
OBJ. XX. Some have been converted at the sacrament.