10, 11. And not only ( å ï ) (i.e. not only have we an example of the election of a son of Abraham by one woman, and the rejection of a son by another, but also of election and rejection of the children of the same woman, Rebecca, and that before they were born. οὐμόνονδέ introduces an àfortiori consideration.
In the construction supply τοῦτο only), but when Rebecca also had conceived (see ref. Num. and ch. Romans 13:13, where the meaning is not exactly the same though cognate) by one man (in the former case, the children were by two wives; the difference between that case and this being, that there, was diversity of parents, here, identity. The points of contrast being then this diversity and identity, the identity of the father also is brought into view. This is well put by Chrys.: ἡγὰρῬεβέκκακαὶμόνητῷἸσαὰκγέγονεγυνή, καὶδύοτεκοῦσαπαῖδας, ἐκτοῦἸσαὰκἔτεκενἀμφοτέρουςἀλλ ʼ ὅμωςοἱτεχθέντεςτοῦαὐτοῦπατρὸςὄντες, τῆςαὐτῆςμητρός, τὰςαὐτὰςλύσαντεςὠδῖνας, καὶὁμοπάτριοιὄντεςκαὶὁμομήτριοι, καὶπρὸςτούτοιςκαὶδίδυμοι, οὐτῶναὐτῶνἀπήλαυσαν. Hom. xvi. p. 610), our father Isaac ( ô. ð á ô. ἡμ., probably said without any special reference, the Apostle speaking as a Jew. If with any design it might be, as Thol. remarks, to shew that even among the Patriarchs’children such distinction took place.
Christians being τέκναἐπαγγελίας, the expression might apply to them: but, as the same Commentator observes, the argument here is to shew that not all the children of promise belonged to the ἐκλογή. See ch. Romans 4:1-12. As to the construction here, it is best to regard ἀλλὰκαὶ … ἔχουσα … ἡμῶν as a sentence begun but intercepted by the remark following, and resumed in another form at ἐῤῥ. αὐτῇ ),—for (not answering to ‘furnishes us an example’supplied after ἔχουσα, but elliptically put, answering to the apprehension in the Apostle’s mind of the force of the example which he is about to adduce. For this use of ã Ü ñ see John 4:44, note; Herod. i. 8, Ã ý ã ç, οὐγὰρ.…; 30, ξεῖνεἈθ. ð á ñ ʼ ἡμέαςγὰρ.…Thucyd. i. 72, τῶνδὲἈθ. ἔτυχεγὰρ …; and other examples in Hartung, Partikellehre, i. 467) without their having been yet born (the subject, the children, is to be supplied partly from the fact of her pregnancy just stated, partly from the history, well known to the readers.
ì Þ instead of οὐ is frequently used by later Greek writers in participial clauses: Winer, edn. 6, § 55. 5; so Acts 9:9, ἦν … μὴβλέπωνκ. οὐκἔφαγεν …, and Luke 13:11, μὴδυναμένηἀνακύψαι. See Schäfer, Demosth. iii. 395, and Hartung, ii. 130–132) or having done anything good or ill ( φαῦλ. an unusual word with Paul = properly ἁπλοῦν, ῥᾴδιον, εὐτελές, as Timæus in Lex. to Plato, with whom it is a very common word in this sense. Ruhnken, on the word in Timæus, gives from the Lex. Rhetor. MS., τὸφ. σημαίνειδέκαἐπίτεπροσώπουκαὶπράγματοςτὸκακόν. τὸμικρόν, ê. τὸεὐκαταφρόνητον, ê. τὸἀσθενές. ê. τὸἄδοξον. ê. τὸἀνόητον, ê. ô. ë. This will shew the connexion of the strict and the wider meaning), [to the end] that the purpose of God according to (purposed in pursuance of, or in accordance with, or (Thol.) with reference to His) election (Thol. prefers taking ê á ô ʼ ἐκλ. adjectively, as Bengel has rendered it, ‘propositum electivum,’and as in Polyb. vi. 34. 8, εἷςἑκάστηςἀνὴρλαμβάνεταικατ ʼ ἐκλογήν, ‘electively’) may (not might; the purpose is treated as one in all time, which would be nullified if once thwarted) abide (stand firm; the opposite of ἐκπίπτειν, see reff. 1 Pet., Isa.),—not [depending on] works (ch.
Romans 3:20; Romans 4:2) but on Him that calleth,—(this clause does not seem to depend on any one word of the foregoing or following, as on ἐῤῥέθη, Calv., Luth.;—or μένῃ, Rückert, Meyer;—or ê á ô ʼ ἐκλογήν, Fritz.;—but to be a general characteristic of the whole transaction; see a similar ἐκ in ch. Romans 1:17. Thol., De W.
Thus viewed, or indeed however taken, it is decisive against the Pelagianism of the Romanists, who by making our faith as foreseen by God the cause of our election, affirm it to be ἐξἔργων. See the matter discussed in Thol.),—it was said to her ( ὅτι is recitantis; the LXX have ê á ß ), “The elder shall serve the younger” (this prophecy is distinctly connected in Genesis 25 with the prophetic description of the children as two nations,— λαὸςλαοῦὑπερέξει, καὶὁμείζωνκ. ô. ë. But the nations must be considered as spoken of in their progenitors, and the elder nation = that sprung from the elder brother. History records several subjugations of Edom by the kings of Judah; first by David (2 Samuel 8:14);—under Joram they rebelled (2 Kings 8:20), but were defeated by Amaziah (2 Kings 14:7), and Elath taken from them by Uzziah (2 Kings 14:22); under Ahaz they were again free, and troubled Judah (2 Chronicles 28:16-17, compare 2 Kings 16:6-7),—and continued free, as prophesied in Genesis 27:40, till the time of John Hyrcanus, who (Jos. Antt. xiii. 9. 1) reduced them finally, so that thenceforward they were incorporated among the Jews): as it is written, Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated (there is no necessity here to soften the ‘hated’into ‘loved less:’the words in Malachi proceed on the fullest meaning of ἐμίσησα, see Romans 9:4 there, “The people against whom the LORD hath indignation for ever”).