That
Matthew wrote a gospel in Hebrew, although denied by many, is at
present the prevailing opinion among scholars, and may be accepted as a
fact both on account of its intrinsic probability and of the testimony
of the Fathers, which begins with the statement of Papias, quoted by
Eusebius in chap. 39, below, is confirmed by Irenæus (III. 1. 1,
quoted below, V. 8, §2),—whether independently of Papias or
not, we cannot say,—by Pantænus (but see below, Bk. V. chap.
10), by Origen (see below, VI. 25), by Jerome (de vir. ill.
3),—who says that a copy of it still existed in the library at
Cæsarea,—and by Epiphanius (Hær. XXIX. 9). The
question as to the relation of this Hebrew original to our present
Greek Matthew is much more difficult. That our Greek Matthew is a mere
translation of the original Hebrew was once a prevailing theory, but is
now completely abandoned. That Matthew himself wrote both is a common
conservative position, but is denied by most critical scholars, many of
whom deny him the composition even of the Hebrew original. Upon the
theory that the original Hebrew Matthew was identical with the
“Gospel according to the Hebrews,” see chap. 27, note 8.
Upon the synoptic problem, see above, II. 15, note 4; and see the works
mentioned there for a discussion of this original Matthew, and in
addition the recent works by Gla, Original-Sprache des Matt.
Evang., 1887, and Resch, Agrapha, Leipzig, 1889.
The very natural reason
which Eusebius gives for the composition of Matthew’s
Gospel—viz. that, when on the point of going to other nations, he
committed it to writing, and thus compensated them for the loss of his
presence—occurs in none of the earlier reports of the composition
of the Gospel which we now possess. It was probably a fact which he
took from common tradition, as he remarks in the previous sentence that
tradition says “they undertook it from
necessity.”