Nestorius was not unnaturally
indignant at this misrepresentation of his words, and complains of
Cyril for leaving out important clauses and introducing additions of
his own. Gieseler Vol. I. p. 231. Cyril succeeded in pressing upon
Celestinus the idea that Nestorius, who had vigorously opposed the
Pelagians, was really in sympathy with them, and so secured the
condemnation of his opponent at Rome and at Alexandria, and published
twelve anathemas to complete his own vindication. These were answered
by Theodoret on behalf of the eastern church in 431. In 433 formal
peace was made, so far as the theological, as apart from the personal,
dispute was concerned, by the acceptance by both John of Antioch and
Cyril of the formula, slightly modified, which Theodoret himself had
drawn up at Ephesus two years before. Gieseler i. 235. It is as
follows: “We confess our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, the
only begotten, to be perfect God and perfect man, of a reasonable soul
and body, begotten before the ages of the Father, as touching His
godhead, and in the last days on account of us and our salvation (born)
of the Virgin Mary as touching His manhood; that He is of one substance
with the Father as touching His godhead, of one substance with us as
touching His manhood; for there is made an union of two natures;
wherefore we confess one Christ, one Son, one Lord. According to this
meaning of the unconfounded union we confess the holy Virgin to be
‘θεοτόκος’ on account of God the Word being made flesh and
becoming man, and of this conception uniting to Himself the temple
taken of her. We acknowledge that theologians use the words of
evangelists and apostles about the Lord some in common, as of one
person, and some distinctively, as of two natures, and deliver the
divine as touching the Godhead of the Christ, and the lowly as touching
His manhood.” Synod. c. 17. Mansi V. p. 773.