Chapter 1.—That the Cause of the Roman Empire, and of All Kingdoms, is Neither
Fortuitous Nor Consists in the Position of the Stars.189
The cause, then, of the greatness of the Roman empire is neither fortuitous nor fatal,
according to the judgment or opinion of those who call those things fortuitous which either
have no causes, or such causes as do not proceed from some intelligible order, and those
things fatal which happen independently of the will of God and man, by the necessity of a
certain order. In a word, human kingdoms are established by divine providence. And if
any one attributes their existence to fate, because he calls the will or the power of God itself
by the name of fate, let him keep his opinion, but correct his language. For why does he
not say at first what he will say afterwards, when some one shall put the question to him,
What he means by fate? For when men hear that word, according to the ordinary use of
the language, they simply understand by it the virtue of that particular position of the stars
which may exist at the time when any one is born or conceived, which some separate alto-
gether from the will of God, whilst others affirm that this also is dependent on that will.
But those who are of opinion that, apart from the will of God, the stars determine what we
shall do, or what good things we shall possess, or what evils we shall suffer, must be refused
a hearing by all, not only by those who hold the true religion, but by those who wish to be
the worshippers of any gods whatsoever, even false gods. For what does this opinion really
85
amount to but this, that no god whatever is to be worshipped or prayed to? Against these,
however, our present disputation is not intended to be directed, but against those who, in
defence of those whom they think to be gods, oppose the Christian religion. They, however,
who make the position of the stars depend on the divine will, and in a manner decree what
character each man shall have, and what good or evil shall happen to him, if they think that
these same stars have that power conferred upon them by the supreme power of God, in
order that they may determine these things according to their will, do a great injury to the
celestial sphere, in whose most brilliant senate, and most splendid senate-house, as it were,
they suppose that wicked deeds are decreed to be done,—such deeds as that, if any terrestrial
state should decree them, it would be condemned to overthrow by the decree of the whole
human race. What judgment, then, is left to God concerning the deeds of men, who is Lord
both of the stars and of men, when to these deeds a celestial necessity is attributed? Or, if
they do not say that the stars, though they have indeed received a certain power from God,
who is supreme, determine those things according to their own discretion, but simply that
His commands are fulfilled by them instrumentally in the application and enforcing of such
necessities, are we thus to think concerning God even what it seemed unworthy that we
should think concerning the will of the stars? But, if the stars are said rather to signify these
189 On the application of astrology to national prosperity, and the success of certain religions, see Lecky’s
Rationalism, i. 303.
That the Cause of the Roman Empire, and of All Kingdoms, is Neither Fortuitous Nor Consists in the Position of the Stars.
209
That the Cause of the Roman Empire, and of All Kingdoms, is Neither Fortuitous…