Julius was induced by all these reasons to undertake the
defense of Athanasius and of Paul: the latter had arrived in Italy not
long previously, and had lamented bitterly these calamities. When
Julius perceived that what he had written to those who held the
sacerdotal dignity in the East was of no avail, he made the matter
known to Constans the emperor. Accordingly, Constans wrote to his
brother Constantius, requesting him to send some of the bishops of the
East, that they might assign a reason for the edicts of deposition
which they had passed. Three bishops were selected for this purpose;
namely, Narcissus, bishop of Irenopolis, in Cilicia; Theodore, bishop
of Heraclea, in Thrace; and Mark, bishop of Arethusa, in Syria. On
their arrival in Italy, they strove to justify their actions and to
persuade the emperor that the sentence passed by the Eastern Synod was
just. Being required to produce a statement of their belief, they
concealed the formulary they had drawn up at Antioch, and presented
another written confession
Athan. de Synodis, 25, and given in full by
Soc. ii. 18.
which was equally at variance with the doctrines approved at
Nicæa. Constans perceived that they had unjustly entrapped both
Paul and Athanasius, and had ejected them from communion, not for
charges against his conduct, as the depositions held, but simply on
account of differences in doctrine; and he accordingly dismissed the
deputation without giving any credit to the representations for which
they had come.