4.
Donation of
Constantine
.
This most remarkable of
forgeries for its practical effect on world-history has been the
subject of endless discussion. It is, in brief, a supposed grant to the
Pope of Rome, Silvester, of certain sweeping privileges in recognition
of the miracle he has wrought. The edict gives a long confession of
faith followed by an account of the miracle and mention of the churches
he has built. Then follow the grants to Silvester, sovereign Pontiff
and Pope of Rome, and all his successors until the end of the
world,—the Lateran palace, the diadem, phryginus, the purple
mantle and scarlet robe, imperial scepters, insignia, banners and the
whole imperial paraphernalia, as well as various clerical privileges
and pretty much the whole world to govern. It is impossible here even
to represent in outline the history of this extraordinary fiction.
Composed not earlier than the latter part of the eighth century
(Martens et alt. 9 cent.; Grauert, 840–850; Hauck, Bonneau,
752–757; Langen, 778, &c.; Friedrich acc. to Seeberg, divides
into an earlier [653] and a later [753] portion), it early came to be
general, though not unquestioned, authority. In 1229–1230 a
couple of unfortunates who ventured to doubt its authenticity were
burned alive at Strasburg (Documents communicated by Ristelhuber to
Bonneau p. 57–58). Not many years after, Dante seems (
Inf
.
19. 115) to have taken its authenticity for granted; and although there
is a possible doubting (
De Monarch
. 4. 10), he does not venture
to dispute this. He denies, however, Constantine’s power or right
to give, if he did give. In modern times the fictitious character of
the document is recognized by Protestants and Catholics alike, and the
discussion, so vigorous for
merly, over this authenticity
has narrowed itself chiefly to a discussion of the place (France or
Rome) and date (653–753, ninth century) and possible author. The
discussion over these points has been lately renewed and is being
carried on with animation. Among the later monographs are those of
Martens (1889) and Friedrich (1889, not at hand). The latest treatise
at hand is that of Seeberg in the Theol. Literaturbl. of Jan. 17. 24.
31 of the current year. For farther select literature, compare
Verzeichniss
in Martens; for sources, the chapters of Martens
and Preface of Bonneau; for older literature, Muensch. p. 96–97,
and in general the
Literature
of Constantine, in this volume,
although no attempt has been made to exhaust the literature of this
sub-topic there. Treatises on the Donation will be found under the
names of Albani, Altus, Arrhenius, Bachmann, Bayet, Bonneau, Brunner,
Chaulnes, Colombier, Cusa, Friedrich, Genelin, Grauert, Hauck,
Hildebrand, Jacobatius, Kaufman, Krüger, Martens, Muench, Rallaye,
Scheffer-Boichorst, Seeberg, Steuchus, Tacut, Valla, Walther, Wieland,
Zeumer.