288
Previously he had προεδρία now he gains προστασία. As we have seen, a series of aggrand-
izements in fact had prepared for this aggrandizement in law; and various metropolitans of
Asia Minor expressed their contentment at seeing it effected. “It is, indeed, more than
probable that the self-assertion of Rome excited the jealousy of her rival of the East,” and
thus “Eastern bishops secretly felt that the cause of Constantinople was theirs” (Gore’s Leo
the Great, p. 120); but the gratification of Constantinople ambition was not the less, in a
canonical sense, a novelty, and the attempt to enfold it in the authority of the Council of
381 was rather astute than candid. The true plea, whatever might be its value, was that the
Council had to deal with a fait accompli, which it was wise at once to legalize and to regulate;
that the “boundaries of the respective exarchates…were ecclesiastical arrangements made
with a view to the general good and peace of the Church, and liable to vary with the dispens-
ations to which the Church was providentially subjected,” so that “by confirming the ἐκ
πολλοῦ κρατῆσαν ἔθος in regard to the ordination of certain metropolitans (see Ep. of
Council to Leo, Leon. Epist. xcviij., 4), “they were acting in the spirit, while violating the
letter, of the ever-famous rule of Nicæa, τὰ αρχεῖα ἔθη κρατείτο (cp. Newman, Transl. of
Fleury, iii., 407). It is observable that Aristenus295 and Symeon, Logothetes reckon this
decree as a XXIXth canon (Justellus, ii., 694, 720).
After the renewal of this canon by the Council of Trullo, Gratian adds “The VIIIth
Synod held under Pope Hadrian II., canon xxj.” (Decretum Pars I., Dist. xxij., C. vij.) “We
define that no secular power shall hereafter dishonour anyone of these who rule our patri-
archal sees, or attempt to move them from their proper throne, but shall judge them worthy
of all reverence and honour; chiefly the most holy Pope of Old Rome, and then the Patriarch
of Constantinople, and then those of Alexandria, and Antioch, and Jerusalem.”
Some Greek codices have the following heading to this canon.
“Decree of the same holy Synod published on account of the privileges of the throne of
the most holy Church of Constantinople.”
Tillemont.
This canon seems to recognise no particular authority in the Church of Rome, save
what the Fathers had granted it, as the seat of the empire. And it attributes in plain words
as much to Constantinople as to Rome, with the exception of the first place. Nevertheless
I do not observe that the Popes took up a thing so injurious to their dignity, and of so dan-
gerous a consequence to the whole Church. For what Lupus quotes of St. Leo’s lxxviij. (civ.)
letter, refers rather to Alexandria and to Antioch, than to Rome. St. Leo is contented to
destroy the foundation on which they built the elevation of Constantinople, maintaining
that a thing so entirely ecclesiastical as the episcopate ought not to be regulated by the
295 Such is not the case in Aristenus as found in Beveridge, Tom. I., p. 147.
535
Canon XXVIII.