Chapter 11.—15. They ask also, "Whether sins are remitted in baptism in the party of
Donatus:" so that, if we say that they are remitted, they may answer, then the Holy Spirit
is there; for when by the breathing of our Lord the Holy Spirit was given to the disciples,
He then went on to say, "Baptize all nations in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and
of the Holy Ghost."1179 Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose
soever sins ye retain, they are retained."1180 And if it is so, they say, then our communion
is the Church of Christ; for the Holy Spirit does not work the remission of sins except in
the Church. And if our communion is the Church of Christ, then your communion is not
the Church of Christ. For that is one, wherever it is, of which it is said, "My dove is but one;
she is the only one of her mother;"1181 nor can there be just so many churches as there are
schisms. But if we should say that sins are not there remitted, then, say they, there is no
true baptism there; and therefore ought you to baptize those whom you receive from us.
And since you do not do this, you confess that you are not in the Church of Christ.
16. To these we reply, following the Scriptures, by asking them to answer themselves
419
what they ask of us. For I beg them to tell us whether there is any remission of sins where
there is not charity; for sins are the darkness of the soul. For we find St. John saying, "He
that hateth his brother is still in darkness."1182 But none would create schisms, if they were
not blinded by hatred of their brethren. If, therefore, we say that sins are not remitted there,
how is he regenerate who is baptized among them? And what is regeneration in baptism,
except the being renovated from the corruption of the old man? And how can he be so
renovated whose past sins are not remitted? But if he be not regenerate, neither does he
put on Christ; from which it seems to follow that he ought to be baptized again. For the
apostle says, "For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ;"1183
and if he has not so put on Christ, neither should he be considered to have been baptized
in Christ. Further, since we say that he has been baptized in Christ, we confess that he has
put on Christ; and if we confess this, we confess that he is regenerate. And if this be so, how
does St. John say, "He that hateth his brother remaineth still in darkness," if remission of
his sins has already taken place? Can it be that schism does not involve hatred of one’s
brethren? Who will maintain this, when both the origin of, and perseverance in schism
consists in nothing else save hatred of the brethren?
17. They think that they solve this question when they say: "There is then no remission
of sins in schism, and therefore no creation of the new man by regeneration, and accordingly
1179 Matt. xxviii. 19.
1180 John xx. 23.
1181 Song of Sol. vi. 9.
1182 1 John ii. 11.
1183 Gal. iii. 27.
Chapter 11
714
Chapter 11