And this he shows very plainly
by his contention against our arguments, where he says that “the
essence of the Son came into being from the Father, not put forth by
way of extension, not separated from its conjunction with Him that
generated Him by flux or division, not perfected by way of growth, not
transformed by way of change, but obtaining existence by the mere will
of the Generator.” Why, what man whose mental senses are not
closed up is left in ignorance by this utterance that by these
statements the Son is being represented by Eunomius as a part of the
creation? What hinders us from saying all this word for word as it
stands, about every single one of the things we contemplate in
creation? Let us apply, if you will, the definition to any of the
things that appear in creation, and if it does not admit the same
sequence, we will condemn ourselves for having examined the definition
slightingly, and not with the care that befits the truth. Let us
exchange, then, the name of the Son, and so read the definition word by
word. We say that the essence of the earth came into being from
the Father, not separated by way of extension or division from its
conjunction with Him Who generated it, nor perfected by way of growth,
nor put forth by way of change, but obtaining existence by the mere
will of Him Who generated it. Is there anything in what we have said
that does not apply to the existence of the earth? I think no one would
say so: for God did not put forth the earth by being extended, nor
bring its essence into existence by flowing or by dissevering Himself
from conjunction with Himself, nor did He bring it by means of gradual
growth from being small to completeness of magnitude, nor was He
fashioned into the form of earth by undergoing mutation or alteration,
but His will sufficed Him for the existence of all things that were
made: “He spake and they were generated Cf. Ps. xxxiii. 9, and Ps.
cxlviii. 5, in LXX. (reading ἐγεννήθησαν).,” so that even the name of
“generation” does not fail to accord with the existence of
the earth. Now if these things may be truly said of the parts of the
universe, what doubt is still left as to our adversaries’
doctrine, that while, so far as words go, they call Him
“Son,” they represent Him as being one of the things that
came into existence by creation, set before the rest only in precedence
of order? just as you might say about the trade of a smith, that
from it
come all things that are wrought out of iron; but that the instrument
of the tongs and hammer, by which the iron is fashioned for use,
existed before the making of the rest; yet, while this has precedence
of the rest, there is not on that account any difference in respect of
matter between the instrument that fashions and the iron that is shaped
by the instrument, (for both one and the other are iron,) but the one
form is earlier than the other. Such is the theology of heresy touching
the Son,—to imagine that there is no difference between the Lord
Himself and the things that were made by Him, save the difference in
respect of order.