Chapter XXI.—Of the
Difference Between Discipline and Power, and of the Power of the
Keys.
If the apostles understood these (figurative
meanings of the Law) better, of course they were more careful (with
regard to them than even apostolic men). But I will descend even
to this point of contest now, making a separation between the
doctrine
of apostles and their
power
. Discipline
governs a man, power sets a seal upon him; apart from the fact that
power is the Spirit, but the Spirit is God. What, moreover, used
(the Spirit) to teach? That there must be no communicating with
the works of darkness.
966
Observe what He
bids. Who, moreover, was able to forgive sins? This is His
alone prerogative: for “who remitteth sins but God
alone?”
967
and, of course, (who
but He can remit)
mortal
sins, such as have been committed
against Himself,
968
and against His
temple? For, as far as you are concerned, such as are chargeable
with offence against you personally, you are commanded, in the person
of Peter, to forgive even seventy times sevenfold.
969
And so, if it were agreed that even the
blessed apostles had granted any such indulgence (to any crime) the
pardon of which (comes) from God, not from man, it would be competent
(for them) to have done so, not in the exercise of discipline, but of
power. For they both raised the dead,
970
which
God alone (can do), and restored the debilitated to their
integrity,
971
which none but Christ
(can do); nay, they inflicted plagues too, which Christ would not
do.
For it did
not beseem Him to be severe who had come to suffer. Smitten were
both Ananias
972
and Elymas
973
—Ananias with death, Elymas with
blindness—in order that by this very fact it might be proved that
Christ had
had the power
of doing even
such
(miracles). So, too, had the prophets (of old) granted to the
repentant the
pardon
of murder, and therewith of adultery,
inasmuch as they gave, at the same time, manifest proofs of
severity
.
974
Exhibit
therefore even now to me,
975
apostolic sir,
prophetic evidences, that I may recognise your divine virtue, and
vindicate to yourself the
power
of remitting such sins!
If, however, you have had the functions of
discipline
alone
allotted you, and (the duty) of presiding not imperially, but
ministerially;
976
who or how great are
you, that you should grant indulgence, who, by exhibiting neither the
prophetic nor the apostolic character, lack that virtue whose property
it is to indulge?
“But,” you say, “
the
Church
has the power of forgiving sins.” This I
acknowledge and adjudge more (than you; I) who have the Paraclete
Himself in the persons of the new prophets, saying, “The Church
has the power to forgive sins; but I will not do it, lest they commit
others withal.” “What if a pseudo-prophetic spirit
has made that declaration?” Nay, but it would have been
more the part of a subverter on the one hand to commend himself on the
score of clemency, and on the other to influence all others to
sin. Or if, again, (the pseudo-prophetic spirit) has been eager
to affect this (sentiment) in accordance with “the Spirit of
truth,”
977
it follows that
“the Spirit of truth” has indeed the
power
of
indulgently granting pardon to fornicators, but
wills
not to do
it if it involve evil to the majority.
I now inquire into your opinion, (to see) from what
source you usurp this right to “the Church.”
If, because the Lord has said to Peter,
“Upon this rock will I build My Church,”
978
“to thee have I given the keys of the heavenly
kingdom;”
979
or, “Whatsoever
thou shalt have bound or loosed in earth, shall be bound or loosed in
the heavens,”
980
you therefore presume
that the power of binding and loosing has derived to you, that is, to
every Church akin to Peter, what sort of man are you, subverting and
wholly changing the manifest intention of the Lord, conferring (as that
intention did) this (gift) personally upon Peter? “
On
thee
,” He says, “will I build My Church;” and,
“I will give
to thee
the keys,” not
to the
Church
; and, “Whatsoever
thou shalt have loosed or
bound
,” not what
they
shall have loosed or
bound. For so withal the result teaches. In (Peter) himself
the Church was reared; that is,
through
(Peter) himself; (Peter)
himself essayed the key; you see
what
(key): “Men of
Israel, let what I say sink into your ears: Jesus the Nazarene, a
man destined by God for you,” and so forth.
981
(Peter) himself, therefore, was the
first to unbar, in Christ’s baptism, the entrance to the heavenly
kingdom, in which (kingdom) are “loosed” the sins that were
beforetime “bound;” and those which have not been
“loosed” are “bound,” in accordance with true
salvation; and Ananias he “bound” with the bond of death,
and the weak in his feet he “absolved” from his defect of
health. Moreover, in that dispute about the observance or
non-observance of the Law, Peter was the first of all to be endued with
the Spirit, and, after making preface touching the calling of the
nations, to say, “And now why are ye tempting the Lord,
concerning the imposition upon the brethren of a yoke which neither we
nor our fathers were able to support? But however, through the
grace of Jesus we believe that we shall be saved in the same way as
they.”
982
This sentence
both “loosed” those parts of the law which were abandoned,
and “bound” those which were reserved. Hence the
power of loosing and of binding committed to Peter had nothing to do
with the capital sins of believers; and if the Lord had given him a
precept that he must grant pardon to a brother sinning against
him
even “seventy times sevenfold,” of course He
would have commanded him to “bind”—that is, to
“retain”
983
—
nothing
subsequently, unless perchance such (sins) as one may have committed
against
the Lord
, not against a
brother
. For the
forgiveness of (sins) committed in the case of a
man
is a
prejudgment against the remission of sins against
God
.
What, now, (has this to do) with the Church, and
your
(church), indeed, Psychic? For, in accordance with
the person of Peter, it is to
spiritual
men that this power will
correspondently appertain, either to an apostle or else to a
prophet. For the very Church itself is, properly and principally,
the Spirit Himself, in whom is the Trinity of the One
Divinity—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
984
(The Spirit) combines that Church which the Lord has made to consist in
“three.” And thus, from that time forward,
985
every number (of persons) who may have
combined together into this faith is accounted “a Church,”
from the Author and Consecrator (of
the Church). And accordingly “the
Church,” it is true, will forgive sins: but (it will be)
the Church of the Spirit, by means of a spiritual man; not the Church
which consists of a number of bishops. For the right and
arbitrament is the Lord’s, not the servant’s; God’s
Himself, not the priest’s.
966
Eph. v. 11
. See ch. xviii. above.
967
Mark ii. 7; Luke v. 21
.
968
Comp.
Ps. li. 4
(in LXX.
Ps. l. 6
).
969
Matt. xviii. 22
.
970
Comp.
Acts ix. 36–43; xx.
9–12
.
971
Comp.
Acts iii. 1–11; v.
13–16
.
972
Acts v. 1–6
.
973
Acts xiii. 6–12
.
974
Comp.
2 Sam. xii. 1–14
, etc.
975
Kaye suggests
“apostolica et prophetica”—“apostolic and
prophetic evidences;” which is very probable.
976
Comp.
1 Pet. v. 1–4
.
977
Comp.
John xv. 26
.
978
Matt. xvi. 18
.
979
Matt. xvi. 19
ad init
., incorrectly.
980
Matt. xvi. 19
.
981
Acts ii. 22
et seqq.
982
See
Acts xv. 7–11
.
983
Comp.
John xx. 23
.
984
See
de Or
., c.
ii.
985
See
Matt. xviii. 20
.