Of this Domninus we know only what is told us here. It is
suggested by Daniell (in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. IV. 630)
that this shows that the prohibition uttered by Severus against the
Jews “must have been soon relaxed, if it ever was
enforced.” But in regard to this it must be said, in the first
place, that Severus’ decree was not levelled against the Jews,
but only against conversion to Judaism,—against the fieri,
not the esse, Judæos. The object of the edict was not to
disturb the Jews in the exercise of their national faith, but to
prevent their proselyting among the non-Jewish residents of the empire.
If Domninus, therefore, fell from Christianity into Judaism on account
of the persecution, it seems highly probable that he was simply a
converted Jew, who gave up now, in order to avoid persecution, his new
faith, and again practised the religion of his fathers. Nothing,
therefore, can be concluded from Domninus’ case as to the
strictness with which Severus’ law was carried out, even if we
suppose Domninus to have fallen from Christianity into Judaism. But it
must be remarked, in the second place, that it is by no means certain
that Eusebius means to say that Domninus fell into Judaism, or became a
Jew. He is said to have fallen into “Jewish will-worship”
(ἐκπεπτωκότα
ἐπὶ τὴν
᾽Ιουδαϊκὴν
ἐθελοθρησκείαν). The word ἐθελοθρησκεία
occurs for the first time in Col. ii. 23, and means
there an “arbitrary, self-imposed worship” (Ellicott), or a
worship which one “affects” (Cremer). The word is used
there in connection with the Oriental theosophic and Judaistic errors
which were creeping into the churches of Asia Minor at the time the
epistle was written, and it is quite possible that the word may be used
in the present case in reference to the same class of errors. We know
that these theosophizing and Judaizing tendencies continued to exert
considerable influence in Asia Minor and Syria during the early
centuries, and that the Ebionites and the Elcesaites were not the only
ones affected by them (see Harnack, Dogmengesch. I. 218 sq.).
The lapse of any one into Ebionism, or into a Judaizing Gnosticism, or
similar form of heresy—a lapse which cannot have been at all
uncommon among the fanatical Phrygians and other peoples of that
section—might well be called a lapse into “Jewish
will-worship.” We do not know where Domninus lived, but it is not
improbable that Asia Minor was his home, and that he may have fallen
under the influence of Montanism as well as of Ebionism and Judaizing
Gnosticism. I suggest the possibility that his lapse was into heresy
rather than into Judaism pure and simple, for the reason that it is
easier, on that ground, to explain the fact that Serapion addressed a
work to him. He is known to us only as an opponent of heresy, and it
may be that Domninus’ lapse gave him an opportunity to attack the
heretical notions of these Ebionites, or other Judaizing heretics, as
he had attacked the Montanists. It seems to the writer, also, that it
is thus easier to explain the complex phrase used, which seems to imply
something different from Judaism pure and simple.