11. They fall into the same folly with the
Arians; for Arians also say that He was created for us, that He might
create us, as if God waited till our creation for His issue, as the one
party say, or His creation, as the other. Arians then are more bountiful to us
than to the Son; for they say, not we for His sake, but He for ours,
came to be; that is, if He was therefore created, and subsisted, that
God through Him might create us. And these, as irreligious or more so,
give to God less than to us. For we oftentimes, even when silent, yet
are active in thinking, so as to form the results of our thoughts into
images; but God they would have inactive when silent, and when He
speaks then to exert strength; if, that is, when silent He could not
make, and when speaking He began to create. For it is just to ask them,
whether the Word, when He was in God, was perfect, so as to be able to
make. If on the one hand He was imperfect, when in God, but by being
begotten became perfect De
Syn. 24, n. 9; Or. i. 14, n. 7., we are the cause
of His perfection, that is, if He has been begotten for us; for on our
behalf He has received the power of making. But if He was perfect in
God, so as to be able to make, His generation is superfluous; for He,
even when in the Father, could frame the world; so that either He has
not been begotten, or He was begotten, not for us, but because He is
ever from the Father. For His generation evidences, not that we were
created, but that He is from God; for He was even before our
creation.