Elucidations
I.
(Deception, cap. ix.
p. 538
.)
More and more, the casuistry exposed
by Pascal in the
Provincial Letters
3701
becomes
an important subject for the investigation of Americans. Nobody who
has any pretensions to scholarship can afford to be ignorant of these
letters; for they belong to literature, and not merely to theology. But
they belong in a sense to the past; not that “the Society of
Jesus” has ceased to maintain all that Pascal has exposed,
and to practice even worse, but that the Latin churches have, since
the days of Pascal, been formally subjected to a system of casuistry,
in some respects superficially reformed, but in all other respects
radically bad, and corrosive to society. In Pascal’s day this
casuistry could only be charged upon individuals, and upon societies
and communities: the Roman Church everywhere adopted it, but was not
formally committed to it. But in the system of Liguori this corrupt
morality has been made authoritative and
dogmatic;
so that in
all the Latin churches it becomes the base of the confessional. For
moral purposes, it is the Bible of the millions who resort to their
confessors and “directors.” These remarks, however, are
here introduced merely with reference to the morals of Clement with
regard to truth.
3702
I have briefly indicated, in the footnotes, the
points which are to be noted in forming an opinion of our
author’s conceptions of this vital principle. They seem to me
conformed to the Gospel; to the teachings of Him who allows no
hair-splittings, but says, “Let your yea be yea,
and your nay, nay.” But, as
the text stood in the Edinburgh translation, it did injustice to Clement
in one passage, which I have modified. It reads, “He (the Gnostic)
both thinks and speaks the truth, unless, at any time, medicinally, as
a physician for the safety of the sick, he may
lie,
or tell an
untruth.” To this, Clement adds significantly, “according to
the Sophists.” That is to say, our author tolerates the Christian
who has not got beyond the
Sophists
with respect to benevolent
deceptions. As
killing
is not always
murder,
so some,
even among stern moralists, have maintained that
deception
by word of mouth is not always
lying.
This is the extent
to which Clement tolerates sophistry, and he goes on to demand the
practice of
truth
in Gospel terms. Now, thank God, the English
word “lie” is always infamous; and there is nothing like
it, in this respect, in other languages. The Sophists themselves
did not so understand the Greek word (
ψεῦδος
),
when they apply it to the benevolent deception of a physician,
or to the untruths used benevolently with the insane. Nothing
infamous attaches to the French word
mensonge
when used for what are
deemed “innocent deceptions.” With this whole system of
sophistry I have no patience at all; but, in justice to the Sophists,
let us not make them worse than they were. They did not understand
that such deceptions were
lies.
Hence, for “lie,”
I have used the word
deceive,
correcting a needless rendering of
the text, and one to which Clement should not be made to extend even a
contemptuous toleration.
In this respect, the holy Jeremy Taylor and Dr.
Johnson go further than Clement, and seem to allow that benevolent
deceptions may be innocent. Sanderson sustains a sterner morality, and
is more generally accepted. Liguori’s system is
verbally
as strong as the Gospel itself: lying is a mortal sin, and never
justifiable. But, when he comes to the definition of a lie, it is made
so feeble, that the worst liar that ever lived need never resort to it.
He may practice all manner of subterfuge, and even perjury, without
telling a lie. As, e.g., if he points up his sleeve, while he swears
that he did not see the criminal
there,
he tells no lie: it is
the business of the judge and jury to watch his fingers,
etc.
II.
(True Gnostic, cap. x. p. 540,
note 1
.)
This unfortunate word
Gnostic
hides the force of Clement’s teaching, throughout this work. Here
he virtually expounds it, and we see that it refers even more to the
heart than to the head. It carries with it
the conduct of life
by knowledge; i.e., by “the true Light which lighteneth every man
that cometh into the world.” (See
p. 607
,
footnote.)
III.
(The Scriptures, cap. xvi.
p. 550
, note 3.)
The Primitive Fathers never dream
of anything as
dogma
which cannot be proved by the Scriptures,
save only that the apostolic traditions,
clearly proved to be such,
must be referred to in proving what is Holy Scripture. It is not possible
to graft on this principle the slightest argument for any tradition not
indisputably apostolic, so far as the
de fide
is concerned.
Quod
semper
is the touchstone, in their conceptions, of all orthodoxy. No
matter who may teach this or that,
now
or in any post-apostolic
age, their test is Holy Scripture, and the inquiry, Was it
always
so taught and understood?
3701
A good translation of the letters was published
in New York, in 1864, by Hurd & Houghton.
3702
For a good article on St. Alphonsus de’Liguori, see the
Encyc.
Britannica
.