Theodoret was at Antioch when
Count Rufus brought him the edict. His friends would have detained him,
but he hurried away. Epp.
LXXIX and LXXX. On reaching Cyrus he
wrote to his friend Anatolius warmly protesting against the cruel and
unjust action taken against him, and informing the patrician that
Euphronius, a military officer, had travelled hard on the track of
Rufus to ask for a written acknowledgment of the receipt of the edict
of relegation. Ep.
LXXIX. The letters written at this crisis by
the indignant pen of the maligned scholar and saint Epp.
LXXIX. LXXX. LXXXI. LXXXII. LXXXIII.
have a peculiar value, at once biographical, literary, and theological.
To Eusebius bishop of Ancyra he sends an important catalogue of his
works. To Dioscorus, the chief of the cabal against him, he sends a
summary of his views on the incarnation and the nature of our Lord,
couched in such terms as might perhaps in earlier days have shortened
his great controversy with Cyril. But the opponents of Theodoret were
not in a mood to be moved by any formulation of the terms of his faith.
Dioscorus received the letter with insult, and publicly joined in the
shout of anathema which he permitted to be raised against his hated
brother. Ep.
LXXXVI. The condemnation of Eutyches by
Flavian’s Constantinopolian Synod had roused the Eutychian party
to leave no stone unturned to secure its reversal and crush it and all
who upheld it. Of the latter Theodoret was the most prominent, the
ablest and perhaps the holiest. Hence he was the natural representative
and personification of the doctrines that Dioscorus sought to decry and
degrade. “Theodoret’s condemnation was the chief object aimed
at in summoning” the Latrocinium. He was “the bugbear of
the whole Eutychian party and consequently condemned in advance.”
Canon Venables, Dict. Christ. Biog. iv. 913 and Martin Brigandage
à Ephèse p. 192. The sixth Council of Ephesus of evil fame
met in the Church of St. Mary the Virgin on August 8, 449. Eutyches was
acquitted. Flavian was condemned. Ibas of Edessa, Domnus of Antioch,
and Theodoret of Cyrus were deprived of their sees. The disgraceful
scenes of violence which marked every stage of this shameful
ecclesiastical gathering have been described again and again with the
vivid detail See
specially Gibbon Chap. xlvii. Milman Hist. Lat. Christ. Book II. Chap.
iv. Stanley, Christian Institutions, Chap. xvi. 4 and Canon
Bright Art. Dioscorus in Dict. Christ. Biog. General Councils, it may
be remarked, have been depreciated and ridiculed by historians of two
kinds; the anti-Christian, such as Gibbon, who have been glad of the
opportunity of bringing discredit on the Church; and the Roman, such as
Cardinal Newman, who are aware that the authority of Councils is not
always reconcileable with the asserted authority of the Bishop of their
favourite see. (“Even those councils which were œcumenical
have nothing to boast of in regard to the Fathers, taken individually,
which compose them. They appear as the antagonist host in a battle, not
as the shepherds of their people.” Hist. Sketches, p. 335.) And
it must be conceded that so far as outward circumstances went the
Latrocinium was as good a council as any other. As is pointed out by
Dean Milman, “It is difficult to discover in what respect, either
in the legality of its convocation or the number and dignity of the
assembled prelates, consists its inferiority to more received and
honoured councils. Two imperial commissioners attended to maintain
order in the council and peace in the city. Dioscorus the patriarch of
Alexandria by the Imperial command assumed the presidency. The Bishops
who formed the Synod of Constantinople were excluded as parties in the
transaction, but Flavianus took his place with the Metropolitans of
Antioch and Jerusalem and no less than three hundred and sixty bishops
and ecclesiastics. Three ecclesiastics, Julian a bishop, Renatus a
presbyter, and Hilarius a deacon were to represent the bishop of Rome.
The Abbot Barsumas (this was an innovation) took his seat in the
Council as a kind of representative of the monks.” Milman, Lat.
Christ. Book II. Chap. iv. The fact is that the great Councils of the
Early Church are like the great men of the Early Church. Some have
authority and some have not. But their authority does not depend upon
formal circumstances or outward position. They have authority because
the inspired common sense of the Church has seen and valued the truth
and wisdom of their utterances. Athanasius, Arius, Cyril, and
Nestorius, were all great churchmen. Athanasius and Cyril stand out
against the background of centuries as champions of the faith. Arius
and Nestorius are counted as heretics. Character does not outweigh
doctrine. Nestorius is unsound in the faith though he was an amiable
and virtuous man; Cyril is an authority of orthodoxy though his
personal qualities were not saintly. Of all the councils that according
to Ammianus Marcellinus hamstrung the postal resources of the Empire,
take Nicæa, Tyre, and the two Ephesian councils of 431 and 449.
Nicæa and the earlier Ephesian are accepted by the Church
Catholic. Tyre and the later Ephesian, though both were summoned at the
will of princes and attended by a large concourse of bishops, are
rejected. Why? The earlier Ephesian in the disorder and violence of its
proceedings was as disgraceful as the Tyrian and the later Ephesian.
The councils of Nicæa and of Ephesus, called the first and the
third œcumenical councils, are vindicated by the assent of the
wisest of the Church. The dictum securus judicat orbis terrarum
here holds good, and is seen to be identical with the ultimate
foundation of the great Aristotelian definition “defined by
reason, and as the wise man would define.” And such is also the
practical outcome of the statement of Article XXI, of the Church of
England.
cf. the striking passage
of Augustine (Cont. Maximin. Arian. ii. 14). “Sed nunc nec ego
Nicænum, nec tu debes Ariminense, tanquam prœjudicaturus,
proferre consilium. Nec ego hujus auctoritate, nec tu illius detineris.
Scripturarum auctoritatibus, non quorumque propriis, sed utrisque
communibus testibus, res cum re, causa cum causa, ratio cum ratione
concertet.” On the first four accepted œcumenical
councils Dr. Salmon (Infallibility of the Church, p. 287)
remarks, “Gregory the Great says that he venerates these four as
the four Gospels, and describes them as the four square stones on which
the structure of faith rests. Yet the hard struggle each of these
councils had to make and the number of years which the struggle lasted
before its decrees obtained general acceptance, show that they obtain
their authority because of the truth which they declared and it was not
because of their authority that the decrees were recognised as
true.” rendered possible by the exactitude
of contemporary narrative, but, inasmuch as Theodoret was condemned in his absence
we are concerned here less with the manner in which his condemnation
was brought about than with the steps he took to protest against and to
reverse it.