On the other hand, towards the patriarch of
Constantinople, when he considered him guilty of uncanonical procedure,
he assumed a distinctly authoritative attitude. On his own
authority he declared null and void (as his predecessor Pelagius II.
had done) the synod at which the title of œcumenical bishop had
been conferred on the Constantinopolitan patriarch (Lib. V.,
Epp. 18, 21); he entertained the appeal to himself of the two
presbyters John and Athanasius, reversed their condemnation by the
patriarch of Constantinople, and ordered their restitution (Lib.
VI., Epp. 14, 15, 16, 17, &c.); and in a letter to John of
Syracuse he says, “Nam de Constantinopolitana ecclesia quod
dicunt, quis eam dubitet sedi apostolicæ esse
subjectam?” (Lib. IX., Ep. 12.)
For the See of Constantinople, though now patriarchal, was not even an
ancient sedes apostolica: its bishop had indeed been
assigned honorary rank (τὰ
πρεσβεῖα τῆς
τιμῆς) next after the bishop of
Rome by the general Council of Constantinople (a.d. 381), but this only on the political ground of
Constantinople being new Rome: patriarchal jurisdiction had
indeed been confirmed to it over the Metropolitans of the Pontic,
Arian, and Thracian dioceses by the 28th Canon of the Council of
Chalcedon (a.d. 451); but this Canon had been
repudiated at the time by Pope Leo of Rome. Hence the popes were
ever peculiarly jealous of any new assumption, or uncanonical
proceedings, on the part of the Constantinopolitan See, the ascendancy
of which signified to them imperial domination rather than
primitive ecclesiastical order or prerogative: and hence it is
not to be wondered at that on the assumption of a title that seemed to
imply universal supremacy Gregory was at once in arms, and asserted
strongly all the authority that he believed to be inherent in his own
Apostolic See. Such assertion, however, had no immediate effect
in the absence of power to enforce it: it was disregarded at
Constantinople: the Emperor Mauricius, who alone could have given
practical effect to it, was appealed to by Gregory in vain; and, though
Phocas, who succeeded him, is said to have issued a decree that
“the Apostolic See of St. Peter, that is the Roman Church, should
be the head of all Churches” (Anastasius Bibliothec.), yet
it is an historical fact that neither Constantinople nor the Churches
of the East generally, ever submitted to the claims of the Roman
See.