martyrdom.475 In this imprisonment he wrote his second epistle to Timothy,476 in which
he mentions his first defense and his impending death.
that defend the genuineness of the Pastoral Epistles assume a second imprisonment, though some (e.g. Wieseler,
Ebrard, Reuss and others) defend the epistles while assuming only one imprisonment; but this is very difficult.
On the other hand, most opponents of the epistles (e.g. the Tübingen critics and the majority of the new critical
school) deny the second imprisonment. As to the place where Paul spent the interval—supposing him to have
been released—there is again a difference of opinion. The Pastoral Epistles, if assumed to be genuine, seem to
necessitate another visit to the Orient. But for such a visit there is no ancient tradition, although Paul himself,
in the Epistle to the Philippians, expresses his expectation of making such a visit. On the other hand, there is an
old tradition that he visited Spain (which must of course have been during this interval, as he did not reach it
before the first imprisonment). The Muratorian Fragment (from the end of the second century) records this
tradition in a way to imply that it was universally known. Clement of Rome (Epistle to the Corinthians, c. 5.) is
also claimed as a witness for such a visit, but the interpretation of his words is doubtful, so that little weight can
be laid upon his statement. In later times the tradition of this visit to Spain dropped out of the Church. The
strongest argument against the visit is the absence of any trace of it in Spain itself. If any church there could
have claimed the great apostle to the Gentiles as its founder, it seems that it must have asserted its claim and the
tradition have been preserved at least in that church. This appears to the writer a fatal argument against a journey
to Spain. On the other hand, the absence of all tradition of another journey to the Orient does not militate against
such a visit, for tradition at any place might easily preserve the fact of a visit of the apostle, without preserving
an accurate account of the number of his visits if more than one were made. Of the defenders of the Pastoral
Epistles, that accept a second imprisonment, some assume simply a journey to the Orient, others assume also
the journey to Spain. Between the spring of 63 a.d., the time when he was probably released, if released, and the
date of his death (at the earliest the summer of 64), there is time enough, but barely so, for both journeys. If the
date of Paul’s death be put later with Eusebius and Jerome (as many modern critics put it), the time is of course
quite sufficient. Compare the various Lives of Paul, Commentaries, etc., and especially, among recent works,
Schaff’s Church Hist. I. p. 231 sqq.; Weiss’ Einleitung in das N. T. p. 283 sqq.; Holtzmann’s Einleitung, p. 295
sqq.; and Weizsäcker’s Apostolisches Zeitalter, p. 453 sqq.
475 See below, chap. 25, note 6.
476 Eusebius looked upon the Pastoral Epistles as undoubtedly genuine, and placed them among the Homo-
logumena, or undisputed writings (compare Bk. III. chaps. 3 and 25). The external testimony for them is very
strong, but their genuineness has, during the present century, been quite widely denied upon internal grounds.
The advanced critical scholars of Germany treat their non-Pauline authorship as completely established, and
many otherwise conservative scholars follow their lead. It is impossible here to give the various arguments for
or against their genuineness; we may refer the reader particularly to Holtzmann’s Die Pastoralbriefe, kritisch
und exegetisch behandelt (1880), and to his Einleitung (1886), for the most complete presentation of the case
against the genuineness; and to Weiss’ Einleitung in das N. T. (1886), p. 286 sqq., and to his Commentary on
the Pastoral Epistles, in the fifth edition of the Meyer Series, for a defense of their genuineness, and also to
Woodruff’s article in the Andover Review, October, 1886, for a brief and somewhat popular discussion of the
224
Paul having been sent bound from Judea to Rome, made his Defense, and was…