by a nominal appellation, nor can the incorporeal nature of supramundane powers name
God by voice and tongue. For, in the case of immaterial intellectual nature, the mental energy
is speech which has no need of material instruments of communication. For even in the
case of human beings, we should have no need of using words and names if we could other-
wise inform each other of our pure mental feelings and impulses. But (as things are), inas-
much as the thoughts which arise in us are incapable of being so revealed, because our nature
is encumbered with its fleshly surrounding, we are obliged to express to each other what
goes on in our minds by giving things their respective names, as signs of their meaning.
But if it were in any way possible by some other means to lay bare the movements of
thought, abandoning the formal instrumentality of words, we should converse with one
another more lucidly and clearly, revealing by the mere action of thought the essential nature
of the things which are under consideration. But now, by reason of our inability to do so,
we have given things their special names, calling one Heaven, another Earth, and so on, and
as each is related to each, and acts or suffers, we have marked them by distinctive names,
so that our thoughts in regard to them may not remain uncommunicated and unknown.
But supramundane and immaterial nature being free and independent of bodily envelopment,
requires no words or names either for itself or for that which is above it, but whatever utter-
290
ance on the part of such intellectual nature is recorded in Holy Writ is given for the sake of
the hearers, who would be unable otherwise to learn what is to be set forth, if it were not
communicated to them by voice and word. And if David in the spirit speaks of something
being said by the Lord to the Lord1168, it is David himself who is the speaker, being unable
otherwise to make known to us the teaching of what is meant except by interpreting by
voice and word his own knowledge of the mysteries given him by Divine inspiration.
All his argument, then, in opposition to the doctrine of conception I think it best to
pass over, though he charge with madness those who think that the name of God, as used
by mankind to indicate the Supreme Being, is the result of this conception. For what he is
thinking of when he considers himself bound to revile that doctrine, all who will may learn
from his own words. What opinion we ourselves hold on the use of words we have already
stated, viz. that, things being as they are in regard to their nature, the rational faculty im-
planted in our nature by God invented words indicative of those actual things. And if any
one ascribe their origin to the Giver of the faculty, we would not contradict him, for we too
maintain that motion, and sight, and the rest of the operations carried on by the senses are
effected by Him Who endowed us with such faculties. So, then, the cause of our naming
God, Who is by His nature what He is, is referable by common consent to Himself, but the
liberty of naming all things that we conceive of in one way or another lies in that thing in
our nature, which, whether a man wish to call it conception or something else, we are quite
1168 Ps. cx. 1.
545
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.