It is difficult to judge from a solitary work what the
degree of an author’s general culture is. Clemens Alexandrinus
has multitudinous quotations; it would be easy to conclude that he was
a scholar of universal reading, and a genuine polyhistor; but their
inaccuracy and frequent infelicity make them rather appear as the
excerpts from some florilegium or some rhetorical hand-book. The
classical allusions in Sozomen are not very many; and he might well
have considered it out of place to indulge in overmuch reference in
such a record as he presents; the quality of what appears would not
compel a wide range of reading; the dedication is most fertile in
familiar illustrations, poetical, historical, and mythological. In i.
6, because of his mentioning Aquilis, he drags the Argonauts in by the
ears, hardly from Pisander, but rather from Zosimus, who does the same
in mentioning the progress of Alaric.
Zos. v. 29.
When he describes Constantine’s tentative search for a favorable
site on which to rear his new capital, the mention of the plain of
Ilium moves the historian to relate a little tradition about the Trojan
town (ii. 3). He mentions Aristotle, in whose philosophy Aëtius
was versed (iii. 15); and to whose dialectic work Theophronius composed
an introduction (vii. 17). When he dwells on the imitative literature
produced by Apolinarius, he alludes indirectly to the Homeric poems,
and mentions outright his writing “comedies in imitation of
Menander, tragedies resembling those of Euripides, and odes on the
model of Pindar” (v. 18). In narrating the history of Daphne
under Julian (v. 19), he gives the myth of Apollo and Daphne. Such
hints and others are no proof or disproof of any extensive reading, and
yet the way in which he alludes to some is more after a cyclopædic
fashion than any profound study of the authors themselves. In fact, his
confession in the instance of the Apollo and Daphne myth is naive,
“I leave this subject to those who are more accurately acquainted
with mythology.” This acknowledgment is not born of any puritanic
hesitancy,—for he had ventured into the sensual bog a little way
already,—but is rather a genuine declaration of his ignorance,
and that in the capital where Anthemius and Synesius were authorities.
Probably we have a little light in the limitations and illiberality of
his early training, by recalling his attitude toward the imitative
writings of Apolinarius, which sprang up to countervail the Julian
edict, which the Christians interpreted as a prohibition to their
enjoyment of the Hellenic culture. While Socrates whole-souledly and
forcibly advocates the humanizing effect of the ancient literature
(iii. 16), Sozomen says, “Were it not for the extreme partiality
with which the productions of antiquity are regarded, I doubt not but
that the writings of Apolinarius would be held in as much estimation as
those of the ancients,” and he rather sides with the monks in
their contempt for classic studies (i. 12). He does not wholly commit
himself; he is a bit hesitant,—a characteristic of his make-up.
This was an absorbing question in that and previous days, as it has
continued to agitate the church, more or less, until our own time. In
his time the influence of the monks and the clergy, who were pervaded
with the ascetic spirit, was more and more against the humanities; the
court fluctuated, while the training of the Valentinian and Theodosian
succession had been decidedly monastic, and its sympathies were mainly
with the intolerant tendency, the necessities of their position, and
the splendid and overshadowing political abilities of men like
Libanius, Themistius, Anthemius, Troïlus, could not be set aside.
Some of them, too, had proved themselves to be the saviours and
uplifters of the state. The learning and grace of Eudocia, the empress,
the spirit of her early training as the daughter of an Athenian
philosopher, and her own poetic gifts, were persuasive agents in
sustaining a classical survival among the Christians at the court,
before she fell under the blight of her husband’s jealousy.
Cyrus, the restorer of Constantinople, filled his verses with the same
antique flavor. The clergy, whose preliminary training had been in the
schools of the sophists, or at the Universities, could not wholly bury
their sympathy, although they went through casuistic struggles such as
that of Jerome. The Arians, too,
were frequently of a larger culture, and on the Germanic side, of
signal military skill and political sagacity, whose services the state
could not dispense with. The University which even the monastically
drilled Theodosius the Younger organized in Constantinople, while
seeking to give a Christian tone to the higher education, previously
controlled by Athens, made very liberal provision for the languages, if
not so much for philosophy. Sozomen, as we see, inclined to a less
generous view, and thought Apolinarius had such a universal genius,
that his numerous originals might be dispensed with; Homer, Menander,
Euripides, Pindar, but for an affectation, need not have been missed.
This shows the thin quality of his reading, if not the restricted
quantity of it, and lays bare the impotence of his critical faculty.
These limitations were doubtless due in large measure to the shrunken
ideals of his Palestinian education: it savored of Epiphanius’
temper and impress.