It has not been unfrequently assumed that the word
Theotocos was coined to express the peculiar view of the Incarnation
held by St. Cyril. Such however, is an entire mistake. It
was an old term of Catholic Theology, and the very word was used by
bishop Alexander in a letter from the synod held at Alexandria in
a.d. 320, The date is not
certain, it may have been a year or so different. to condemn
the Arian heresy (more than a hundred years before the meeting of the
Council of Ephesus); “After this, we receive the doctrine of the
resurrection from the dead, of which Jesus Christ our Lord became the
first-fruits; who bore a body in truth, not in semblance, which he
derived from Mary the Mother of God (ἐκ τῆς
Θεοτόκου
Μαρίας).” Theod., Hist.
Eccl., I., 4. The same word had been used by many
church writers among whom may be mentioned St. Athanasius, who says,
“As the flesh was born of Mary, the Mother of God, so we say that
he, the Word, was himself born of Mary” (Orat. c. Arian.,
iij., 14, 29, 33; also iv., 32). See also Eusebius (Vit.
Const., iij., 43); St. Cyril of Jerusalem (Cat., x., 9); and
especially Origen, who (says Bp. Pearson) “did not only use, but
expound at large the meaning of that title Θεοτόκος in his
first tome on the Epistle to the Romans, as Socrates and Liberatus
testify.” Pearson, An Expos. of
the Creed, Art. III., n. 36. (Cf. Origen
in Deut. xxii., 23; vol. ij., p. 391. A; in Luc. apud Galland,
Bib. Patr., vol. xiv., append., p. 87, D). A list is given
by Dr. Routh, in his Reliquiæ Sacræ. Vol. ij., p. 215
(1st Ed.), 332 (2d Ed.).